Search
Are you looking for internal information?
Showing 21001-21020 of 35052 hits
- Playing roulette with fish stocks, sustainably
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
How high a risk are we prepared to take with fish stocks, with fisheries and with the marine environment? That question is at the heart of the recent move by the European and the Council to amend the multiannual plans for commercial fisheries in the Baltic and other regions. It deserves to be discussed openly. So far it hasn’t. In effect, the Commission and the Council are now prepared to take much greater risks than they were a few years ago. This risk-prone behaviour is escalating now, despite the history of stock collapses in the Baltic within the past 10 years. The Council has in practise accepted a one in four risk that fish stocks fall below a limit value instead of accepting a risk of 1 to 20, meaning by coming below this limit, they could crash or be “harmed” in the next year. Moving with unusual speed and without the normal consultations and impact assessments, the Commission has in effect accepted this higher risk. It has proposed, together with the Council, that the Council should be allowed to take similar or even higher risks in the future. Fortunately, the proposal will also be discussed in the Parliament. That gives a bit of time for reflection and discussion on how good an idea this actually is. MAPs The multiannual plans (MAPs) were adopted by the EU as a central tool to achieve sustainable fisheries after the reform of the Common Fisheries policy in 2013. The Baltic MAP, adopted in 2016, was the first, and the model for the others. A key goal of the MAP, and of the CFP, is to restore and maintain levels of commercially fished stocks above levels that can produce “maximal sustainable yield”. But in case they do not succeed, there is a safety catch in the MAP: fishing quotas are to be set in a way that in any case does not give more than a 5% probability that the stocks fall below a crisis level called Blim (the biomass limit, below which reproduction may be impaired, meaning the stock could collapse or being permanently reduced in productivity). Falling below Blim means that the fishery irrevocably should be stopped. Of note, these limits are rather arbitrarily set, and there is a risk that the stocks in the Central Baltic as well as in the Gulf of Bothnia already are reduced in reproductive capacity due to fact that years of overfishing have passed unnoticed. The October surprise Due in part to overly optimistic decisions in the Council, the state of two of the four herring stocks in the Baltic is now so bad that even with no fishing in 2024 they were estimated to have too high a probability of falling below the crisis level in 2025. In accordance with rule 4(6) in the MAP regulation the Commission duly proposed closing the targeted fisheries for them. In doing so, it fudged the definition of “targeted” for one of them, leaving a gaping loophole allowing for an unknown but large amount of herring to be caught as “bycatch” in the sprat fishery. And, implicitly, allowing a much higher level of risk than the regulation permitted. The Council, ostensibly not understanding the MAP-regulation, decided in October to set fishing levels with a much higher level of risk. Then again, they also requested that the Commission start a process to remove the offending safe-guard, suggesting that they did in fact understand that they were breaking the rules. How big a risk is sustainable? According to calculations by ICES (International Council for Exploration of the Sea, the scientific body that does these estimates for the Baltic and Northeast Atlantic) the levels of fishing approved by the Council would give a 20% or larger probability of the stocks falling below the limit level. For the central Baltic herring, the probability is a whopping 29% (assuming the Russians will stick to their fair share of the herring catches, which they haven’t for the past years). That is, the Member States’ fisheries ministers Council are taking a one in four chance of the stock falling into the danger zone, more than five times the level currently allowed in the MAP-regulation. If the Council would make such decisions for a stock four years in a row, statistically, the stock would likely fall below the limit value. Put another way, if the Council would make such a decision for four stocks this year, at least one would be expected to get into the red zone next year. It should be noted that these probabilities are estimates, based on expected growth of the stocks. These growth projections might be loosely compared to the projections made by banks about the growth of the economy, the rate of inflation or the interest rate. That is, they are by nature uncertain. In Baltic fisheries, the uncertainties can be very great, due to misreporting tainting the data fed into the models, environmental changes impacting relations the models are based on, the weather or other uncertainties. So in reality, the probabilities could be lower – or higher. One might compare the odds accepted by the Council with those of a classic Russian roulette, where the odds are in fact better, only one out of six. Serious consequences or sky is the limit? But that raises another question: how serious are the consequences of being unlucky? In Russian roulette, the consequences are very serious for the individual player. But for fish stocks? The consequences for the fishers and the communities where people make a living by catching or processing fish is that people can lose their livelihoods. This is less serious than losing one’s life, but serious enough. The consequences for the marine environment can be more far-reaching and long-lasting. The fishing for the Norwegian spring spawning herring was stopped in the mid-1960s, and the ban lasted for 30 years. However, it saved the most important fish stock in Europe, and Norway can rightly pride themselves on taking the wise and correct decision at the right time. Herring are a key low-trophic level species, interacting with other species both as predator and prey and a motor moving energy flows in the Baltic. The consequences for coastal environments can be enormous, impacting coastal fish species, birds, amplifying the effects of eutrophication etc. A fisher with loans to pay may be willing to take a very large risk with the fish stocks or the environment to avoid having to close down operations. But how big a risk do we as a society want to take with fish stocks and the marine environment beyond next year? How much is sustainable? That is something we ought to discuss more openly before the European Parliament decides if it wants to remove a safeguard or not, and what it wants to put it its place. Would it be enough to amend the 5% rule and accept a 30% probability of a stock entering the danger zone, or, as is the case in the Commission and Council proposal, simply remove the safeguard and accept that the sky is the limit? Text: Charles Berkow
- Tough criticism after Council decision on continued herring fishing
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
There will be no closure for targeted herring fishing in the Baltic Sea next year. On October 24th, EU agriculture and fisheries ministers rejected the European Commission's proposal and decided to continue herring fishing, albeit with reduced quotas.
- ANALYSIS: “Those are our rules, and if you don’t like them, well, we’ll make others”
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
In October, the fisheries ministers in the Council decided to break a rule in European legislation. In December, the Commission proposed to delete the rule. The European Parliament and the Council had made the rules in the first place. Will the Parliament go along with the change? For years, European fisheries ministers agreed on fishing quotas that were unsustainably high. While perhaps popular with some in the fishing industry in the short run, in the longer term the result was depleted fish stocks and poor earnings for fishers. It was, of course, also harmful for the marine environment, though those effects are not as easily noticed in some circles. Probably due to the longer term social and economic impacts of the depleted stocks for coastal communities, the politicians realized that things needed to be done differently. An answer was long-term management plans, with rules for setting fishing quotas that would hopefully lead to more robust fish stocks. Sort of like Odysseus tying himself to the mast so he could listen to the sirens songs without being tempted to crash his vessel. These longer term multiannual plans were a keystone in the reform of the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) in 2013. The first to be adopted, and the template for the others, was the Baltic Sea Multiannual Plan (MAP) , covering seven fish stocks of herring, cod and sprat. Adoption was delayed until 2016 due to a battle between the Council and the European Parliament over who gets to decide on the plan. The Parliament won in court, so the plan was adopted by both co-legislators. In practise it hasn't worked Despite being the result of a somewhat messy compromise between the two institutions, the plan has a certain logic to it. Article 4 contains the rules for setting fishing quotas, or total allowable catches (TACs). Article 5 has some extra safeguards (and some redundancies). Articles 4 and 5 in the multiannual plan A simplified version of Article 4 goes like this: 4.1 sets the overarching goal: TACs should be set within a range of values for the fishing pressure consistent with maximum sustainable yield (FMSY, the range being Fupper to Flower). 4.2 stipulates that these values should be estimated by scientists at the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) or some similar independent scientific body. 4.3 sets the basic rule: TACs should be set between the point value of FMSY and Flower. 4.4 has an optional exception from the basic rule: TACs may always be set lower than Flower. No conditions need to be met. 4.5 has another optional exception: TACs may be set between FMSY and Flower. But only if certain conditions are met. 4.6 has another exception, but this is obligatory: TACs “shall in any event” (in unusually sharp and clear language for EU legislation) be set so that the probability of the stocks falling below a limit level (Blim) is less than 5%. Article 4.6 can be seen as a seat belt: when stocks fluctuate, fishing pressure should be kept low enough so that they do not fall too close to a tipping point where they may collapse. At the time when the MAP was adopted, this seat belt was probably seen as superfluous. After all, the main objective of the CFP reform and the MAP was to restore and maintain stocks at target levels far higher than the limit value. Towards that end, the MAP has safeguards in Article 5. Again, in a simplified version, 5.1 says that when the stock falls below a trigger level (reasonably, below the target level) “all appropriate remedial measures shall be adopted to ensure rapid return of the stock” to levels above the target level. Then it states redundantly that a condition for applying the exception in 4.5 is not fulfilled, so that exception is not allowed. 5.2 says that when the stock falls below the limit level even more “remedial measures shall be taken to ensure rapid return of the stock” to levels above the target level. Then it states redundantly that this may include suspending the targeted fishery. On paper, it looks nice. In practise, it hasn’t worked. Since its adoption in 2016, three of the seven stocks managed by the Baltic Sea Multiannual Plan have crashed, in the sense that ICES has in essentially advised that the targeted fishery be closed. First out was the Western Baltic Spring Spawning herring. For 2018, (under the new MAP) the ICES advice was for a TAC below around 35 thousand tonnes or less. By 2019 the ICES advice was for a 0 catch. It has been there since. Next to crash was the Eastern Baltic cod, (albeit not due to overfishing). For 2018, the ICES advice was for a TAC of about 26 thousand tonnes or less. In the summer of 2019 the fishery was banned. It has been only a low by-catch ever since. Third in line was the Western Baltic cod. For 2018, the ICES advice was for a TAC of about 3.5 thousand tonnes or less. By 2022 the advice was for a TAC of less than 7 hundred tonnes, and that was only by-catch in the flatfish fishery. The advice has been only for by-catches since, dropping to a mere 24 tonnes or less for 2024. The optimist would be disappointed All the remedial measures taken under Article 5 have not prevented the crashes, nor, together with quota cuts (too little, too late) led to a return of the stock to even the limit level, much less the trigger level, not to mention the target level. Nor that the return was to be rapid. Needless to say, with a few short years’ perspective, these developments have not been good for coastal communities or from a socio-economic perspective. An optimist might hope that Baltic fisheries ministers and others involved in setting quotas would learn from these failures. The optimist would be disappointed. If anything, they have played a blame game. Some blame the seals or cormorants. Some blame deteriorating environmental conditions because of global heating or overfertilization of the sea. Some blame the Member States for not following EU environmental rules. Some blame the Russians. Even if there were some truth in all of these (which there might not be), it begs the question: what can you change in the short run, while trying to deal with the climate or eutrophication etc. in the longer term? Commission is removing the safety belt We at the Baltic Sea Centre have pointed out that the TAC decisions are based on forecasts over stock growth, and that they by nature are uncertain . That it is imprudent to base management decisions on the assumption that the growth forecasts will always be realised in full. There are plenty of examples of fish growth forecasts not being realised. It would make sense to apply a bigger precautionary buffer. Instead, the Commission is now proposing to remove the safety belt. This year, the scientists at ICES pointed out that the stocks of herring in the Central Baltic and the Gulf of Bothnia were so close to crashing that it was time to put on the seat belt. That is, the conditions for implementing Article 4.6 in the MAP were fulfilled. The Commission agreed, and duly proposed closing at least the targeted fisheries on the two herring stocks. Fisheries ministers balked: they opted for rather toothless remedial measures instead. Some have pointed out that this was a violation of the EU legislation . The ministers may have silently agreed this: they demanded a change of the rules. And now the Commission has obliged them. Less than a week before the next fisheries ministers meeting, the Commission is proposing to delete Article 4.6 in the Baltic MAP and its counterparts in MAPs covering two other regions. In contorted logic, the Commission now argues that the MAP is inconsistent. It claims that application of the seat belt may not be compatible with other provisions of the MAP, presumably the safeguard “remedial measures” that have failed to deliver. After all, Art. 5.2 only says that targeted fisheries MAY be closed, not that they MUST be closed. That is, its redundancy is not detailed enough. The Commission also says that applying the seat belt may “result in potentially severe socioeconomic implications”. Not reflecting on the socioeconomic implications of two more herring stocks potentially going down the tubes like the cod and Western Baltic herring. And by the way, the Commission asserts that the normal procedure of conducting impact assessments or public consultations is not necessary in this case. After all, it has consulted with the industry-dominated Baltic Sea Advisory Council and the Baltic coastal EU Member states in a presumably closed session of the government cooperation body “BaltFish”. Perhaps the Commission will come to its senses, depending on the reaction to the consultation it opened after presenting its proposal. Up to the Parliament Otherwise, that leaves the Parliament. Who, after all, went to court for the right to be co-legislator on the multiannual plan. Will it also defend its content? Or will it tell the ministers in the Council, in the spirit of Groucho Marx “those are our rules, and if you don’t like them, well, we’ll make others”? Text: Charles Berkow
- Scientists: Don’t look at the 1980's as a reference for the Baltic Sea
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The photos of happy fishermen in the 1980's holding huge cods, almost larger than themselves, are iconic and often contrasted by a small meagre fishes caught today. But this period of time was an anomaly in the Baltic Sea history, and should not be regarded as a reference state, says scientists after having compiled and analysed large quantities of information from the last century. The ecosystem in the Central Baltic Sea has undergone large changes in the 20th century related to climate variability and anthropogenic pressures, in particular eutrophication and commercial fisheries. All of this together, has caused a series of regime shifts; and a general shift in the ecosystem functioning and food-web structure. The Baltic Sea shows large variations when it comes to salinity and temperature. As low salinity is stressful for many organisms, these variations traditionally have had a large impact on Baltic Sea biota. During the second part of the 20th century, however, the deteriorated oxygen conditions in the Central Baltic Sea has gained larger impact on the ecosystem, for example by limiting the areas where cod can reproduce. – One can say that the regulatory driver has switched from salinity to oxygen, says Maciej Tomczak , researcher at Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre and lead author of the study Reference state, structure, regime shifts, and regulatory drivers in acoastal sea over the last century: The Central Baltic Sea case.
- Baltic Breakfast: New methods for environmental monitoring
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
National and international legal acts require monitoring of the environmental status and the demands are increasing. Meanhile, funding does not follow or are even under the threat of cut-backs. Are there ways forward to secure the continued long-term observations with more cost-efficient methods? The latest Baltic Breakfast took a closer look. Aquatic environments are affected by human activities, sometimes dramatically and sometimes in more subtle ways. The key to keep track of changes and what measures are most effective, is environmental monitoring. Through several monitoring programs, large scale impact on, for instance, eutrophication and toxins on biodiversity and ecosystem health are assessed. " This work is vital, and also critical for researchers. The environmental monitoring is the best tool we have to follow ecosystem scale responses to environmental change", said Francisco Nascimento, Associate Professor at the Department of Ecology, Environment and Plant Sciences, Stockholm University. At the same time, demands from environmental goals, legislations and directives are increasing, while funding remains unstable and unpredictable. Nascimento finds these things a challenge to meet. " We can ask ourselves if the traditional methods that we have are sufficient to comply with all new demands and if they can deliver on all these", he said. In his research, Nascimento investigates the possibilities to complement two of the existing monitoring programs in the Baltic Sea with new techniques.
- Baltic Sea Centre on the fishing ban in the Bothnian Sea: "Ineffective"
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Sweden and Finland have agreed to introduce a temporary ban on industrial herring fishing in the Bothnian Sea this summer. The Baltic Sea Centre is critical and argues that the fishing ban must be both extended and prolonged to have any effect.
- Deciphering coastal climate impact: Sandviken Bay exploration
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Is there a difference between healthy and degraded coastal bays in terms of greenhouse gas emissions and uptake? To answer this question, researchers from different disciplines are working together carrying out various measurements along the Swedish coast. Come with us to Sandviken Bay, where the first of several days of a new sampling campaign took place.
- ANALYSIS: High time for a carbon price for fishing
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Is it finally time for European fishing to pay a price for its carbon emissions? It may be, by 2027. That depends largely on Member States. They have been reluctant so far. But the clock is ticking. In reviewing the obligatory national action plans, the Commission should encourage Member States to include fisheries in the emissions trading system at the latest by 2027.
- The State of the Baltic Sea - report and recording available
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The state of the Baltic Sea is still not satisfactory and environmental toxins is a growing problem. This is one of the conclusions in the new HELCOM assessment HOLAS III. A report based on the assessment was recently launched at a webinar moderated by Gun Rudquist, Head of Policy at Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre. HELCOM recently launched the third assessment on the state of the Baltic Sea, HOLAS III. It was presented at a webinar on 30 October, which is now available on line.
- The Commission wants to remove the '5 % rule' for Baltic Sea fisheries
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The so-called '5 % rule' in the multi-annual management plan for the Baltic Sea ensures that fishing pressure is reduced if the biomass of the fish stock is too low. The European Commission now wants to remove this safeguard from the management plan.
- Baltic Breakfast: Messing with the seabed – and below it
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The seabed and the bedrock could play an important role for the green transition; for mining of minerals and storing of carbon dioxide. But the environmental consequences of such activities are not fully understood, showed the presentations at the last Baltic Breakfast.
- Baltic Breakfast: Fisheries regulations and environmental factors behind the strong Riga herring
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Limitation on vessel size, closed periods for fishing and beneficial environmental changes. Those are some possible factors behind the favourable development of the herring stock in the Gulf of Riga, according to the researchers participating in the last Baltic Breakfast.
- Major Baltic Sea research initiative - 12 PhD positions open
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Within a new graduate school in marine, climate and environmental issues, 12 doctoral students at several of Stockholm University's departments will be hired. The graduate school is directed towards students who are interested in understanding their own research in a broad and interdisciplinary context. A particular focus is on deepening the understanding and provide new knowledge of the specific conditions and challenges of the Baltic Sea in a changing climate.
- The proposed new Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive – what happens now?
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Both the European Parliament and the Council have now had their say on the Commission’s proposal for a new Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive. Researcher Bärbel Muller-Karulis and policy analyst Ellen Bruno have been following the process and analysed the outcome so far. Bärbel Muller-Karulis, regarding nutrient removal, what did the other EU bodies say about the Commission’s proposal? "The EU Parliament had its say on the proposal on 5 October and the EU Council on 16 October and both proposed a number of changes. Unfortunately, both Parliament and Council voted to soften the nutrient removal requirements proposed by the Commission. Both proposed that wastewater treatment plants should continue to be allowed to rely on natural nitrogen retention in rivers and lakes to reach removal requirements; permanently according to the Parliament and for a period of 15 years according to the Council. This is problematic since the level of retention is highly uncertain and differs immensely with waterbody characteristics, local climate etc. Both also opted to bypass nitrogen removal requirements altogether during the colder part of the year and suggest that days with wastewater temperatures below 12 degrees should simply be disregarded in removal calculations. Parliament and Council also did not follow the Commission’s strict (and ambitious) definition of 'urban' areas and both would like to apply the directive in areas with a higher population density than the Commission, leaving more effluent in rural areas to be treated in less efficient individual systems."
- New study: How will acidification affect the Baltic Sea by 2100?
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions not only lead to global warming but also cause ocean acidification. According to a new study, pH in parts of the Baltic Sea could decrease by 0.1 units by 2100 if carbon dioxide emissions continue at current levels. With increasing emissions, the reduction could be as large as 0.4 pH units, which could have a major impact on marine life. Ocean acidification has been called the 'evil twin of warming'. While greenhouse gas emissions are increasing carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere, resulting in a warmer climate, levels of carbon dioxide are also increasing in the ocean, causing pH to drop and the ocean to become more acidic. Around a quarter of the carbon dioxide emitted has so far been absorbed by the oceans. “In the world's major oceans, pH has fallen by an average of 0.1 units since the start of industrialisation”, says Erik Gustafsson, oceanographer and researcher at Stockholm University's Baltic Sea Centre. “This may sound small, but it represents a change of more than 30 per cent.”
- Baltic Sea Centre's eutrophication model can provide knowledge about greenhouse gases
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The BALTSEM model is a well-used tool for studying the effects of nutrient inputs to the Baltic Sea and has been used in the HELCOM Baltic Sea Action Plan. The modelling tool has now been further developed to include methane fluxes, which can provide important knowledge about the climate impact of the Baltic Sea.
- Legacy effects are expected to reduce phosphorus loads
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The accumulation of nutrient legacies on land and in inland waters will lead to excessive nutrient loads to the Baltic Sea for still a long time to come, according to a new study. That's one side of the story. On the positive side, measures already taken to reduce the inputs of nutrients to the catchment will have an impact on future loads to the sea as legacies are depleted, thereby reducing the need for additional mitigation measures. In a recently published comprehensive modelling study, researchers at the Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre, have analysed more than a century of nutrient dynamics in the Baltic Sea catchment, covering 1.6 million km2 and 14 countries. The construction of a model enabled them to link the net anthropogenic inputs of nitrogen (NANI) and phosphorus (NAPI) to the Baltic Sea catchment to the waterborne loads to the sea from 1900 and up to today.
- Fisheries experts on the CFP evaluation: “Implementation far from fulfilling its purpose”
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The implementation of the EU Common Fisheries Policy is far from fulfilling its purpose, and there has been too little effort to achieve coherence between fisheries and environmental policy. This is a comment from the Baltic Sea Centre's experts in response to a Commission consultation on the evaluation of the policy.
- Students map the Baltic seafloor
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
When students of the Stockholm University course in Marine Geophysical Mapping Methods collect sediment cores from the bottom of the Baltic Sea, the cores are immediately used in research. No sample material is wasted. The ability to map the seabed is a much sought-after skill in today's job market. For the second day in a row the research vessel Electra af Askö sets sail with students from the Marine Geohysical Mapping Methods course on board. The day before, they learned how to use multibeam sonar and penetrating echosounder to get a picture of the seafloor topography and uppermost sediment depositions. Today they will take sediment cores from two selected locations on the bottom profile. Used in groundwater research
- Professor Maren Voss recieves Baltic Sea award for her pioneering research
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The first ever Björn Carlsson Baltic Sea award, "Björn Carlssons Östersjöpris", will be awarded to Professor Maren Voss from Germany for her groundbreaking research on the role of nitrogen in the eutrophication of the Baltic Sea. On Friday, June 3, professor Voss will receive 3 million SEK in a ceremony at at the Baltic Sea Science Center at Skansen.