Search
Are you looking for internal information?
Showing 20981-21000 of 35052 hits
- Amending the MAP: A Proposal to Withdraw
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre has sent in a response to the EU-Commission’s consultation on its proposal to weaken the multiannual plan for major commercial Baltic fisheries. The Centre suggests that the proposal be withdrawn. In substance it would mean a higher level of risk for further decline or collapse for Baltic fisheries. The process leading up to the proposal was also deficient. For example, no analysis was made of the socio-economic consequences beyond the first year, of the higher risk level, not to mention the consequences for fish stocks or the environment. The Commission’s justification for the amendment is based on a misunderstanding of both the science and of the logic and structure of the plan. The decline of most fish stocks covered by the plan points instead to the need of a more conservation -oriented approach, instead of an even higher-risk approach. Read the full response here: Feedback to the EU Commission proposal to amend the Baltic MAP
- ANALYSIS: Weakening the management of Baltic fisheries
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The European Commission and the Council’s ministers are moving rapidly towards a revision of the multiannual plans for fisheries. Unfortunately, the haste is not matched by the quality of the proposal or the logic of its justification. On the contrary, the ministers seem to have fundamentally misunderstood both the plans they want to amend, the science that underpins annual decisions on fishing quotas, and how the plans and the science interact, writes Charles Berkow, fisheries policy expert at Baltic Sea Centre. If adopted, these changes will increase the risk that fish stocks will continue to collapse. The losers will be fishers, the associated industries, their communities and, most importantly, the marine environment. This article attempts to clarify the issues. The focus will be on the Baltic, where the first multiannual plan was adopted and where a controversy this autumn sparked the drive to weaken the plans . The controversy, call for change and Commission cave The central tool of the EU’s Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) after the reform in 2013 is multiannual plans (MAPs) for managing fisheries. In May, 2023 scientists at the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) pointed out that the risk for the stocks slipping below a limit level was too high, even if there were no fishing at all. Referring to the provision of the Baltic MAP under these circumstances (article 4.6, also called "the 5% rule"), the Commission proposed in August 2023 a closure of targeted fisheries on these two herring stocks (with a substantial by-catch quota for central Baltic herring in other fisheries). The proposal provoked a strong reaction from both major fishing interests and Member States. They objected to the proposed closure of targeted fisheries and wanted higher quotas for the herring (and sprat). In October, ministers rejected the Commission proposal and instead agreed on large quotas of both central Baltic herring and Gulf of Bothnia herring, while also agreeing on restrictions on trawling herring for limited periods as so-called remedial measures, which are suposed to ensure the rapid increase in the fish stocks. In a statement in connection with the Council decision, the European Commission expressed understanding for the Member States’ request for a targeted amendment to the MAP, but pointedly reminded the Council that “it is notably for the Commission to appreciate the timing and content of any such proposal”. Just a few weeks later, on December 6th, the Commission submitted a proposal for a removal of Article 4.6 in the MAP to the Council and the Parliament. There had been no public consultation and no impact assessment, as is normal procedure before the Commission presents a proposal; the Commission claimed that they weren’t needed. Nonetheless, the same day, the Commission in a case of mixed signals, initiated a public consultation on the proposal, open until the end of January 2024. The Working Party on Fisheries Policy (that is, civil servants from the governments in the Member States) examined the proposal already the next day. The Council Presidency presented a compromise (with little change in substance from the Commission proposal) that the Working Party examined and approved on the 18th of December. At least two Member States, however, entered “parliamentary scrutiny reservations” , giving their parliaments a chance to express an opinion. The presidency compromise was then sent to the Permanent Representatives Committee (COREPER) for formal approval, or further discussion, if needed. Two lines of argument In essence, the Commission has two lines of argument. The first is that there may be “inconsistencies” between article 4.6 in the MAP on the one hand and Article 2 and/or Article 5 on the other. The second is that applying the 5% rule could “have potentially severe socio-economic implications”. Article 4 is about setting fishing quotas for the coming year (a more detailed presentation may be found here ). Claiming inconsistency is like comparing apples and oranges The Commission claims that the safeguard in Article 4.6 is essentially redundant. It points out that the main rule for setting TACs is that quotas should be set between F-ranges estimated by ICES, and, crucially, that these values are capped such that the probability of the stock falling below Blim is no more than 5%. This follows from the definition of “range of FMSY values” in Article 2(2). (see Box below) The 5% rule in Article 4.6 is, however, not the same as the 5% rule in Article 2.2. The two 5% rules are based on different time frames and different levels of concreteness. The 5% rule in 4.6 is about the actual risk over the next year based on the most up-to-date information. The 5% rule in 2(2) is about hypothetical risks over the long term , based on simulations often covering 50 or more years. In other words, there are no inconsistencies between the 5% rules in Articles 4.6 and 2(2), except that 5% refers to different entities. Put more simply, it is like comparing apples and oranges: they are both round fruits, but they are different. Evidence that 5% rule for F-ranges in Article 2.2 does not apply to the next year can be seen in the latest ICES advice for the central Baltic herring and Gulf of Bothnia herring. There, ICES presents F-ranges that give a probability of SSB<Blim in 2025 of over 20%. Dropping the 5% safeguard in Article 4.6 in favour of the 5% definition in Article 2.2 means increasing the risk for a stock collapse. From the Baltic MAP: "Article 2.2 'range of FMSY' means a range of values provided in the best available scientific advice, in particular from ICES or a similar independent scientific body recognised at Union or international level, where all levels of fishing mortality within that range result in maximum sustainable yield (MSY) in the long term with a given fishing pattern and under current average environmental conditions without significantly affecting the reproduction process for the stock in question. It is derived to deliver no more than a 5 % reduction in long-term yield compared to the MSY. It is capped so that the probability of the stock falling below the limit spawning stock biomass reference point (Blim ) is no more than 5 %. Article 4.6 Fishing opportunities shall in any event be fixed in such a way as to ensure that there is less than a 5 % probability of the spawning stock biomass falling below Blim. Article 5 Safeguards 1. When scientific advice indicates that for a given year the spawning biomass of any of the stocks referred to in Article 1(1) is below the MSY Btrigger, all appropriate remedial measures shall be adopted to ensure rapid return of the stock concerned to levels above those capable of producing MSY. In particular, notwithstanding Article 4(3), fishing opportunities shall be set at levels consistent with a fishing mortality that is reduced below the upper range of FMSY, taking into account the decrease in biomass. 2. When scientific advice indicates that the spawning stock biomass of any of the stocks referred to in Article 1(1) is below the Blim, further remedial measures shall be taken to ensure rapid return of the stock concerned to levels above the level capable of producing MSY. In particular, those remedial measures may include, notwithstanding Article 4(3), suspending the targeted fishery for the stock and the adequate reduction of fishing opportunities. 3. Remedial measures referred to in this Article may include: (a) emergency measures in accordance with Articles 12 and 13 of Regulation (EU) No 1380/2013; (b) measures pursuant to Articles 7 and 8 of this Regulation….” Article 4.6 vs. 5 The Commission claims (in recitals 8-11) that there may be inconsistencies between Article 4.6 and Article 5. A detailed and somewhat technical comparison between Articles 4.6 and 5 (see box below) show that is not the case. Articles 4.6 and 5 compared: Article 4 in the MAP is about setting fishing quotas for the coming year. Article 5 is about extra protective measures to be taken in some specified circumstances. Starting points: Article 4.6 takes as its starting point the forecast situation next year: the estimated the probability of the spawning stock biomass (SSB) being below the biomass limit level (Blim) Article 5 takes as its starting point the estimated situation this year: 5.1 refers to a situation where the estimated SSB is below a trigger level, MSY Btrigger, while 5.2 refers to a situation where the estimated biomass is below the lower limit level Blim Targets: Article 4.6 has a very clear target: the probability of the spawning stock biomass (SSB) being below the biomass limit level (Blim) shall be less than 5%. Article 5 has the loftier but possibly vaguer target of “return of the stock to levels above those capable of producing MSY” (maximum sustainable yield). Some argue this should be BMSY (the spawning stock biomass that results from fishing at FMSY for a long time). Not all may agree, but it is unclear what the alternative would be. In any case, ICES does not normally provide information on estimated BMSY although it does provide information on MSY Btrigger. Measures: Article 4.6 has only one measure, the setting of fishing quotas (total allowable catches, or TACs). Article 5 refers to “all appropriate remedial measures”. There is a reference to (presumably non-exhaustive) lists of measures in Articles 7 and 8 in the MAP and in articles 12 and 13 of the basic regulation of the Common Fisheries Policy (1380/2013). Article 5.1 singles out one measure in particular: setting TACs below FMSY (a fishing pressure consistent with achieving Maximum Sustainable Yield). Article 5.2 singles out another measure in particular, suspending the targeted fishery and setting TACs at levels to provide only by-catch of the particular stock (for example cod) when targeting other species (for example plaice). Timing: Article 4.6 says nothing about the timing. The most reasonable interpretation is that it refers to the following year, as Article 4 is about setting fishing quotas and they are normally set for the following year. None of the articles 4.3-4.5 specify the time frame, but it is implicit that they refer to TACs for the following year. That is also how they have been applied in practise. If something else is meant in 4.6 that would reasonably be specifically stated there. Article 5 specifically states that the time frame for recovery of stock levels is “rapid”, which, however, is somewhat vague. A close reading of Articles 4.6 and 5 suggests that the differences between them are clear and completely in order. They have different starting points, different targets and different time frames. While there is some overlapping regarding the measures, there is no conflict or problematic “inconsistency” between the two. Severe socio-economic impacts As a closer examination of the alleged inconsistencies between Article 4.6 and other provisions of the MAP shows that there are in fact no such inconsistencies, that leaves the socio-economic impacts as a justification for the change of the MAP. When Member States in the Council refer to “socio-economic impacts” they normally refer to consequences for fishers and the processing industry in the coming year. These consequences are used as arguments for higher quotas than the European Commission has proposed and/or ICES advised are compatible with the MAP. However, the short-term consequences must be weighed against the consequences if the stock is perennially depleted or crashes. When stocks are held at anemic levels for year after year the catches are less than they would be if the stocks were more robust. A short-term reduction in catches can then be seen as an investment in larger stocks and catches in the medium term. As no impact analysis has been presented for the Council/Commission proposal it appears that it is only the impacts in the immediate term that are being considered. The impacts on the marine environment are seldom mentioned but can be assumed to be severe when top predators like the Baltic cod or low-trophic level keystone species like the Baltic herring are depressed. Before an amendment is approved it would be useful for the Council and Commission to present their assessments on the socio-economic and environmental impacts of the proposed changes. Next steps As a result of the consultation it has opened after the fact, the Commission may realize that its proposed change of the MAP was based on a misunderstanding of the MAP and the science and withdraw the proposal. If the Council and Commission maintain their current positions the proposal will go to a three-way “trialogue” negotiation with the European Parliament. It will then be up to the Parliament to defend the integrity of the MAP for which it fought for the status of co-legislator. Then again, perhaps someone will appeal the decisions made under the MAP to the Court of Justice so it can determine if they are consistent with the provisions in the basic regulation of the CFP. Text: Charles Berkow
- ANALYSIS: Forgetting the deal
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The recent and unusually rapid moves by the European Commission and the Council to weaken the management plan for major Baltic fisheries raise the question of if they may have forgotten parts of their deal about how to achieve better law-making, writes Charles Berkow in an analysis.
- PFAS back to haunt us – through sea spray
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The man-made, and in many cases hazardous, chemicals called PFAS were previously believed to finally be transported to and diluted in the oceans. But at the last Baltic Breakfast, scientists at Stockholm University presented new research showing that these chemicals are enriched at the sea surface and return to land through sea spray aerosols, creating an almost never-ending transportation cycle. PFAS – Per- and Polyfluorinated Substances – is an extremely large group of man-made chemicals containing fluorine and carbon atoms that bind together multiple times. The substances are known for their water and grease resistant properties and are used in various industries and consumer products. They also have in common that they are extremely stable and don’t degrade in the environment. In many cases they are bioaccumulating, meaning they are stored and concentrated in living organisms. “They are essentially everywhere”, says Matt Salter, scientist at the Department of Environmental Science, Stockholm University. “They will be in this room in numerous forms.” Some PFAS have been proven harmful for both the environment and for humans, and most use of the substances PFOA and PFOS have already been banned, unfortunately to be replaced with other similar PFAS in many cases. Many different pathways PFAS reach the environment in many different ways; in form of air emissions from production, during use and disposal of consumer products such as waterproof textiles and stain-resistant coatings, and through landfill leachate and wastewater. Another major source is the use of PFAS in firefighting foam, which has caused contamination of land and drinking water.
- Stronger fish stocks and lower subsidies crucial for decarbonising European fisheries
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Measures to decarbonise the European fishing fleet will be less effective and more expensive unless the EU stops subsidizing fuel use and increases fish stocks. That was the main message in a presentation by Charles Berkow of the Baltic Sea Centre in a webinar on the energy transition of the fishing fleet, held in November.
- Baltic Breakfast: The Danish example shows that nitrogen leakage can be reduced
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Increased nutrient efficiency in agriculture and decreasing atmospheric deposition have had large and sustained effects on the Danish river loads of nitrogen. But to reach the goal of the Water Framework Directive, further measures are needed, such as taking areas out of agricultural production, means researcher Gitte Blicher-Mathisen, Aarhus University. Benoît Dessirier, researcher at Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre urges to reconsider today's focus on animal production to build a more resilient system and safeguard the water quality.
- From visionary goal to nutrient input ceilings – new fact sheet describes basis of BSAP
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Goals, objectives, targets, NIC and MAI. The eutrophication segment of Baltic Sea Action Plan is filled of puzzling terminology. A new fact sheet from the Baltic Sea Centre describes how everything is connected – how the political vision of a healthy sea can be reached via the basin-wise Maximum allowable inputs and the country-wise Nutrient input ceilings. Last year, an updated version of the HELCOM Baltic Sea Action Plan was approved by all countries around the Baltic Sea, as well as the EU. The goal of the plan is to restore the common sea to a healthy and resilient state, and a prerequisite for that is that nutrient inputs are significantly reduced. In the BSAP all countries have agreed to reduce their inputs of nitrogen and phosphorus to the sea below a certain ceiling that should ensure that the Baltic would return to a state unaffected by eutrophication.
- Baltic Sea Centre's work highlighted as a good example of knowledge exchange
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Knowledge exchange between marine scientists and policy makers contributes to informed policy decisions and sustainable management of the oceans. But what does it take for such knowledge exchange to be successful? This question has been analysed in a major international study, that highlights the work of the Baltic Sea Centre as a good example. Personal relationships, good timing and the inclusion of many different stakeholders are some important factors that enable knowledge exchange between science and policy or management. This is the conclusion of the researchers behind the new study, Lessons from bright-spots for advancing knowledge exchange at the interface of marine science and policy . The 37 researchers analysed 25 'bright spots' – successful examples of knowledge exchange from around the world – and found that there are several common denominators behind their success. One important part is the personal factors, says Marie Löf , researcher at Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre who participated in the study. – Knowledge exchange is very much about relationships, bringing the right people together and building trust between them. Employees need to be committed and open to new ideas, and it's also important with diversity in the team, she says. The availability of supportive and flexible funding, as well as political demand for the information, are other factors behind successful knowledge exchange. It is also important that there is public support for the issue and that there is a so-called open 'policy window'. – If major long-term political decisions have already been taken on a specific issue, it could mean it’s too late to try to reach politicians with important knowledge that concerns it, however relevant it may be, explains Marie Löf. Contributed to ban on microplastics Two examples of effective knowledge exchange at the Baltic Sea Centre are included in the study. One concerns microplastics, where the Centre, as one of several actors, communicated on a scientific basis about the risks and effects early on. Researchers and environmental analysts participated in multiple meetings with politicians, authorities, industry representatives and other stakeholders, compiled scientific knowledge in an easily accessible form and communicated in the media. Eventually, this led to Sweden introducing a national ban on microplastics in rinse-off personal care products. – This, in turn, contributed to the ECHA, the European Chemicals Agency, proposing even broader restrictions on microplastics. I also believe that we have contributed to a greater awareness of microplastics as a pollutant, says Marie Löf, who has been actively working on the issue herself. The other example is eutrophication, where the Baltic Sea Centre has worked for a long time to persuade decision-makers to invest in science-based measures. – Some measures may seem attractive because they are relatively easy to implement, but they are not the most effective in tackling eutrophication in the Baltic Sea, says Marie Löf. – Politicians have changed their minds and adapted party policies after meetings with us, and even the Swedish Agency for Marine and Water Management has become more nuanced on this issue. Knowledge exchange is often ‘invisible’ Knowledge exchange is a long-term effort that is often rather invisible while it is going on, Marie Löf stresses. – It can ultimately have a big impact on policy decisions, but the result is often the sum of very many small interactions. For the Baltic Sea Centre, knowledge exchange and the dissemination of knowledge and scientific results to different actors in society are key functions, and included in the centre's statutes. – I think that more organisations should work in this way, but it takes time and resources and you have to be prepared to invest these. The success of the Baltic Sea Centre is very much based on the fact that our policy analysts have a long-term relationship with politicians and other stakeholders, and know what issues they are grappling with and can provide them with knowledge from a large network of researchers. Another success factor of the Baltic Sea Centre has been its affiliation with Stockholm University, says Marie Löf. – We have no other agenda than to ensure that decisions are made on a scientific basis and that they lead to a better environment for the Baltic Sea. About the study The study Lessons from bright-spots for advancing knowledge exchange at the interface of marine science and policy was carried out by 37 researchers from different universities around the world. The work was led by Denis Karcher and a core team consisting of Chris Cvitanovic , Ingrid van Putten and Rebecca Colvin . The researchers analysed 25 good examples of successful knowledge exchange between marine science and policy and management. All examples participated in a qualitative study. The study examined, among other things, what initiated the knowledge exchange, what its objectives were, how it was done, what was achieved and what contributed to its success. The main factors that enabled knowledge exchange success were divided into five different groups:
- Baltic Breakfast: Environmental changes impact benthic fauna – and the whole food web
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The inputs of nutrients and harmful substances to the Baltic Sea have changed the distribution and composition of the animals living in and on the seafloor. But the whole ecosystem has also undergone several regime shifts during the last century. At the last Baltic Breakfast, Eva Ehrnsten and Maciej Tomczak shared their research on this topic.
- New study: Cod's latest crisis is not due to lack of oxygen
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The crisis for Baltic cod is often associated with oxygen deficiency, oxygen-free bottoms and a lack of bottom animals that cod can eat. But now, a new Finnish-Swedish study shows that oxygen conditions have been quite adequate for cod in the southern Baltic Sea for several decades – and that there have been plenty of bottom animals above the halocline.
- Baltic Breakfast: Actions in agriculture to improve nutrient use efficiency – the Danish case
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The possibilities to improve nutrient use efficiency in the Baltic Sea region is the topic of upcoming Baltic Breakfast is about. Benoit Dessirier, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre, will present new modelling results regarding magnitude and dynamics of nutrient legacies in agricultural landscapes in the Baltic region and how they contribute to river loads to the sea. Gitte Blicher-Mathisen, Aarhus University, will describe the actions taken in Denmark to reduce nutrient leakage. Adding nitrogen and phosphorous to agriculture arable land is a necessity to get a good crop. But excess nutrient use creates well known problems – leakage of nutrients to surrounding waters causing eutrophication. The fact that nutrients are not used efficiently in agriculture is also old news but to what extent and whether or not actions has an effect, are always relevant for the ongoing agriculture debate. Presently the policy discussions on agriculture are more intense than for a long time. The Ukrainian war inflicts on prices of mineral fertilisers and other inputs leading to even tougher financial situations for farming. EU Member states as well as large parts of the agriculture community, are asking for abandonment of the EU Green Deal’s Farm to Fork strategy’s goal of reducing mineral fertiliser use. At the same time, the global sustainable development goals and other environmental objectives are far from reached and the negative effects of eutrophic waters are obvious. Improved nutrient use efficiency would be good both for eutrophication and for reducing the farming sector’s dependence on inputs such as mineral fertilisers. So, what can research tell us about nutrient use efficiency? What is the situation around the Baltic Sea? Do actions have an effect? Let’s look at what Denmark implemented before 2016 and if it had an effect. Speakers Benoit Dessirier, Researcher, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre Gitte Blicher-Mathiesen, Senior Advisor, Dep of EcoScience, Aarhus University
- Catamaran for research at the Askö Laboratory
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
From the summer 2021 and onwards a new research vessel will replace R/V Limanda. The vessel that was built 2014 is a 15 meters long catamaran that will be used for expeditions in Askös vicinities. At Askö Laboratory there are many boats and vessels that ensure research for many purposes in a large geographical area. They can be used for research, education and marine monitoring. They are also used to transport people from and to the island.
- How the Baltic Sea escaped disaster
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Baltic Sea is highly eutrophic, with anoxic seabeds and large algal blooms. But if the countries surrounding the sea had not reduced nutrient discharges, the situation would have been much worse. “Thanks to the measures taken, the Baltic Sea has avoided an ecological disaster”, says researcher Eva Ehrnstén.
- New policy brief: Safeguard ecosystem function and carbon storage capacity in deep soft bottoms
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Deep soft bottoms are of vital importance for the functioning of the whole marine ecosystem and for long-term carbon storage. This is emphasised by researchers from several different departments at Stockholm University in a new policy brief. They stress that EU Member States must be better at protecting these habitats in the Baltic and North Sea.
- A hot autumn for the Baltic herring
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
This summer, the fisheries debate in Sweden has been hot again. The background is the perilous situation of the Baltic herring. There are fears that it may be following in the tragic footsteps of the Baltic cod. In particular, fishers are still not finding enough large herring in the Gulf of Bothnia to supply the industries producing the iconic regional delicacy, fermented herring (surströmming). The decline of the herring – a keystone species in the Baltic ecosystem, as well as a culturally and economically important catch – has led to a number of other interesting questions being raised. In particular, Sweden’s leading morning daily has had a series of articles delving deeper into marine fisheries issues. Examples include reports of rampant misreporting of species in the herring and sprat fisheries, highlighting the dominance of industrial herring fishing for fish meal, the impact of industrial fishing on small-scale or coastal fishers, the negative consequences of the introduction of individual transferable quotas (ITQ) for pelagic fisheries such as herring, the role of fisheries lobbyists and revolving doors and the amount of subsidies such as exemption from normal fuel taxes. Examples of media coverage (in Swedish) The fermented herring in danger - at risk of collapse Political demands after fisheries audit - stop industrial trawlers in the Baltic Sea Here, the Baltic Sea fish turns into fish meal "If grandfather had lived, he would have blown up their boats" The father of the ITQ system: "I have regrets" Fisheries lobbyists push towards trawling in protected areas in the Baltic Sea Half a billion in subsidies to fisheries - bad business for society Broad support for action There is broad public support for stronger measures to protect the Baltic herring, and in particular reducing or banning industrial trawling. A number of political parties inside and outside of the government have expressed interest in banning industrial trawling within the 12 nautical mile zone from the Swedish coast. But there are different opinions on whether the EU basic regulation on the Common Fisheries Policy (CFP) would allow such a ban could be enforced on vessels from Finland and Denmark. (More technically, if Article 20 would take precedence over Annex I point 12 or not.) In Sweden, an increasing number of voices have also spoken out in favour of a more general ban on industrial trawling in the Baltic. Here it is even more apparent that action on the EU level is needed. Initiatives and call for protection (in Swedish) Swedish Government - The industrial trawling in the Baltic Sea Several parties want to stop monster trawlers in Stockholm Stop the destructive industrial trawling fisheries The herring could soon remain a memory They demand action on the herring fisheries Stop the industrial trawlers before it is too late Rare opportunity to protect threatened fish stocks At the Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre we have identified an opportunity for the Swedish government to act in a way that is completely compatible with the CFP . The government could simply state in a public way that Article 4.6 of the Multiannual Plan (MAP) for Baltic fisheries of herring, cod and sprat should be implemented as written: Fishing opportunities shall in any event be fixed in such a way as to ensure that there is less than a 5 % probability of the spawning stock biomass falling below B lim. The Baltic MAP was adopted in 2016, the first multiannual plan to be adopted after the CFP reform 2013 and a template for the other plans. Other EU multiannual management plans for fisheries include similar provisions. Article 4.6 can be seen as a safeguard. If there is too high of a probability that the stock will fall below the limit value of the spawning stock biomass (Blim) the fishery should be closed. In their latest assessment , scientists at the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES) have estimated that even if there is no fishing at all for herring in the Gulf of Bothnia next year, there will be too high a probability of the stock falling below the limit value. If that happens, the stock may be permanently damaged or the fishery may even collapse. However, ICES has also advised that catches that correspond with the fisheries mortality ranges in the plan are between 48 824 and 63 049 tonnes. Contradictory messages from experts These two messages, on the surface contradictory, might be the result of a compromise between different approaches within ICES. It has happened before that ICES advice has contained contradictory messages . And a member of ICES Advisory Committee has explained on camera in a German television documentary that political aspects have been taken into consideration in preparation of a decision on advice, instead of purely scientific arguments. But, as we wrote in June , ICES places the responsibility for implementing the MAP in the European Commission and the Member States. When the Commission makes its proposal for Baltic total allowable catches for 2024, expected to be in late August, it will show its cards. Will it play the role of the Guardian of the Treaty, take on a role of a Maker of Deals – or kick the can to a later date? This is where signals from Member States, in particular those that actually fish for herring in the Baltic, in particular the Gulf of Bothnia, can be influential. At the fisheries council in October it will ultimately be up to the Member States ministers. They will have to decide if they will abide by the EU legislation in the MAP, adopted by both the Council and the Parliament, or not. What happens in the Baltic herring fisheries this autumn may be a precedent for following decisions in the CFP, both for herring and other fish stocks, both in the Baltic and in the EU waters of the Atlantic. Will the EU follow its own rules, and apply its own safeguards, or will it breach the rules to risk further depletion or collapses of European fisheries? As the end of a hot European summer is approaching, it is shaping up to be a hot autumn for the Baltic herring and European fisheries policy. Text: Charles Berkow
- How to make science for policy relevant and still stay independent
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Citizens and academia want knowledge to reach society to a larger extent, but time, resources and professional academic rewarding systems are getting in the way. How to promote collaboration between scientists and decision-makers was a hot topic when Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre co-organised a conference on open science. The development of the Paris Agreement's target of limiting global warming to 1.5°C shows both the opportunities and risks of co-production of knowledge in societal issues. – We often think that this target came from science, but it was actually adopted in 2015 by decision-makers in Paris. They then asked the research community for evidence of the target, and the research community responded that it didn't exist," said Jessica Jewell, Associate professor of Physical Resource Theory at Chalmers University of Technology, at the conference Open Science - From Policy to Practice . Thanks to generous funding and political support for more scientific knowledge, much research could be conducted, which is partly a success story of policy relevant and useful science. But it also illustrates the risk of research being influenced by policy issues. – Scientists already suspected that scenarios for a two degree target were unrealistic, and yet, tons of new knowledge came out about the 1.5 degree target, she said. In contrast, the " throw it over the fence " model was presented, where science is excellent and independent but instead risks avoiding the societal issue and becoming irrelevant. When the same scientists were asked to answer whether it is possible to achieve the target, the response was " limiting warming to 1.5°C is possible within the laws of chemistry and physics ", which was difficult for politicians to translate into a societal context. According to Jessica Jewell, when aiming to combine research and policy, we need to be reminded that the term 'feasible' means different things to researchers than to politicians. – Something that is feasible for a politician is something that society can actually do, while something that is feasible for the researcher is something that solves their mathematical models," she said.
- From simple nets to high-tech tools as future environmental specialists sample the sea
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
A textbook is one thing – reality another. In the master's course ‘Environmental field studies’ students learn how to assess the marine environment in practice, using both simple and advanced methods. – Waders, wellies or barefoot – the choice is yours! The master's students in Environmental Science have brought their brail nets, buckets and identification literature to one of the rocky shores, rich in bladderwrack, close to the Askö Laboratory. The task is to find gravid amphipods whose eggs and embryos can be used as an indicator of the environmental state of the sea. Some of the students slip into waders, others roll up their trousers and enter the water barefoot. They hand over equipment to each other, then fall silent, as they crouch over the water and net through the seaweed. – Take the chance to look at the beautiful river nerites too, says Ann-Kristin Wiklund, researcher and director of studies at the Department of Environmental Science (ACES) at Stockholm University. – We have used those small gastropods in previous studies to investigate the damage caused by toxic anti-fouling paints, she says. Different stressors cause different types of damage Earlier in the morning, the students gathered in the field station's lecture hall and learned about the advantages and difficulties of field studies, and about one of the sub-programmes in the environmental monitoring of the Baltic Sea, on the amphipods Monoporeia affinis and Pontoporeia femorata , which has been running since 1994.
- New study: Methane emissions offset carbon uptake in Baltic macroalgae habitats
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Bladderwrack in the Baltic Sea emits significant amounts of methane, which, to some extent, can offset the uptake of atmospheric carbon dioxide by these algae. This is shown by a new study from Askö Laboratory, where the fluxes of greenhouse gases between surface waters and the atmosphere were measured continuously over several seasons.
- FORCE investigates how sticklebacks affect coasts and climate
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Large predatory fish have become harder to find in the coastal bays of the Baltic Sea, which are now dominated by sticklebacks. Many of these bays have also become more turbid and show signs of severe eutrophication. Scientists have seen this shift spread from the open sea to coastal environments and are now looking for explanations as to why this has happened and whether it could contribute to unforeseen climate impacts. In one of the largest field sampling programmes of the year, the FORCE project map changes and how best to restore coastal predatory fish stocks and biodiversity. From Västervik to Östhammar, the composition of fish species, plants and algae living in 32 different bays will be analysed. In addition, samples of nutrient levels and plankton will reveal the water quality in these areas. The sampling station at Krysshamnsviken in the Stockholm archipelago is a hive of activity, with several fishing nets being thoroughly sorted and rinsed on the adjacent boat jetty and beach, while samples are collected by divers and assistants in a rib boat out in the bay. Krysshamnsviken is one of 32 sites that FORCE researchers surveyed in 2014 to investigate the relationship between fish species, vegetation and water quality. Now, 10 years later, they are back to see how these have developed. " These bays are very different. They have different amounts of predatory fish and sticklebacks, as well as different levels of protection from fishing. The number of seals and cormorants in these areas also vary. In total, this gives us a better picture of the causes and possible measures, such as fishing closures, to improve the environmental status," says Johan Eklöf, Professor in Marine Ecology at the Department of Ecology, Environment and Plant Sciences at Stockholm University and project leader for FORCE. Link between sticklebacks and climate change The decline in predatory fish such as pike and perch and the increase in sticklebacks is affecting many natural values. The situation has contributed to turbid bays with more filamentous algae and severe symptoms of eutrophication. More predatory fish help to keep water areas clean and clear, and could counteract these symptoms. The researchers are now trying to find out whether stronger populations also could be linked to climate effects. " We will investigate whether areas with a lot of predatory fish are better at storing carbon than areas dominated by sticklebacks, where carbon turnover is higher," says Johan Eklöf.
- PhD students connect coast and society in a changing climate
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Solving complex questions about interactions between the sea and climate change, and how they relate to society, requires a broad set of skills. In a new research school, PhD students from diverse scientific disciplines at Stockholm University get a unique opportunity to learn how transdisciplinary approaches and research communication can lead to sustainable management of coastal environments. What unites students in from widely varied subjects like marine geology, business accounting, and ecotoxicology? They all provide important perspectives necessary to answer questions on societal challenges and solutions to climate change in coastal seas. During a kick-off meeting for the research school Perspectives on climate change in coastal seas in March, 14 new PhD students were introduced to this framework that will be their research focus for the coming years. "I feel proud to be part of this program, and though this transdisciplinary context is new to me, I think I have a lot to bring to the table," says Emma Flévaud, PhD student in environmental law. Adding new pieces to the puzzle The oceans face multiple climate-related pressures such as acidification, oxygen deficiency and rising temperatures. These, among others, cause feedbacks that release potent greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, reinforcing the climate effects. However, under healthy conditions with prospering ecosystems, the coastal zones have effective carbon storage capacities and can be important carbon sinks. "If we manage the coastal zones right, they could globally contribute to 20 percent of the greenhouse gas emission reductions we need to fulfill the Paris Agreement," says Christoph Humborg, Scientific Director at Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre and one of the initiators of the research school. This intricate puzzle is partly understood and described in science, and questions remain about the links between climate change, biodiversity and the full potential of the coastal zones to serve as climate mitigators. In research initiatives like CoastClim experts in ecology, modeling, marine physics, and atmospheric sciences explore these links. For the next couple of years, the students from Stockholm University will be involved in research questions that add important information in this context.