Search
You are now searching on the website "Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre". Would you like to search the entire Stockholm University website?
Search on su.seShowing 61-80 of 671 hits
- Reduce coastal trawling to protect the Baltic herring
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
March 2021: Increased herring catches close to the Swedish Baltic east coast, and the negative trend for several herring stocks accentuate the need for reduced fishing pressure and more detailed knowledge about herring subpopulation structure. POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS • Move the trawling border along the Swedish east coast further out (e.g. to 12 nautical miles from the baseline) to secure herring spawning sites and over-wintering areas. • Conduct a more detailed survey of the stock and subpopulation structure and migratory patterns of the Baltic Sea herring, using historical knowledge and new DNA-techniques, cross-checked with other techniques, such as otolith chemistry. • Use the survey results to revise the current structure of management units for Baltic Sea herring to better account for herring subpopulations in fisheries management. • Reduce annual catches to well below Fmsy for Central, Western, and Gulf of Bothnia herring – to safeguard the preservation of stocks, subpopulations, and genetic diversity. • Restrict large-scale herring trawling in times and places with particular risks for coastal ecosystems and local subpopulations, in line with the precautionary principle. The large-scale Swedish trawling for herring in the Baltic Sea has flourished in recent years. The herring catches in the Central Baltic and the Bothnian Sea have increased by 70 percent over the past five years. At the same time, a larger proportion of the fishery has moved closer to the east coast. There are now worrying reports about a decreased abundance of herring in several coastal areas. These concerns include depletion of local herring subpopulations, with grave consequences for coastal ecosystems and lower productivity of the whole herring stock. These signals from the coast, and the overall negative trends for some of the major Baltic Sea herring stocks, call for caution. Fisheries management and stock assessment frameworks should urgently ensure a better and more detailed understanding of 1) the stock- and subpopulation structure of the Baltic Sea herring, and 2) how the current herring fishery affects the coastal ecosystems. In order to halt the negative development, it is also necessary to restrict the large-scale trawling for herring close to the Swedish east coast, in line with the precautionary approach.
- Call for better management of micropollutants in wastewater
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
February 2021: Urban wastewater treatment plants are important collection points for many chemical contaminants, often called micropollutants, which are widespread in the aquatic environment. Currently, this issue is not being sufficiently addressed by regional policy and EU-wide legislation. The EU’s Zero Pollution Ambition, the Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability and the likely revision of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive now provide opportunities to address this issue. Measures to prevent the emissions of micropollutants via wastewater treatment plants are needed both up- and downstream, to ensure policy coherence between EU water and chemicals legislation. POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS In the revision of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive, UWWTD: • develop criteria for minimum chemical wastewater quality that address micropollutants and their mixtures. • establish a clear connection to the Water Framework Directive and the Marine Strategy Framework Directive ensuring that the UWWTD functions as a means of also achieving good chemical/ecological/environmental status of surface waters with regard to CECs and other micropollutants. The connection should allow for flexibility in the definition of good status as science and policy progress. Ensure that the Chemicals Strategy fulfills the ambition to include persistence combined with mobility as additional criterion in, for example, REACH in order to identify hazardous substances. Chemicals with such properties are particularly prone to escape from wastewater treatment processes and contaminate waterways. Organise regular joint screening campaigns under HELCOM to assess the presence of chemicals of emerging concern in wastewater, with the aim of improving our understanding of the extent to which wastewater treatment plants are contributing to the total input of various types of chemicals into the Baltic Sea region and identify potential marine pollutants. Thousands of chemicals are emitted from materials and products in our homes, workplaces and industries. Both well-known environmental pollutants and less studied Contaminants of Emerging Concern (CECs), i.e. chemicals that have only recently been identified as potentially harmful to the environment, risk contaminating both inland waterways and the sensitive coastal zones of the Baltic Sea. These coastal zones are home to marine organisms during vulnerable life stages, including spawning and juvenile development, when their sensitivity to toxic chemicals is particularly high. There is increasing concern in the research community and society at large regarding the overall ecotoxicological effects of this chemical mixture in our waters. Important collection points
- Fishing ban and more knowledge required to save the European eel
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
November 2020: If the endangered European eel population is to recover there is an urgent need for a fishing ban, increased environmental monitoring and fewer obstacles to migration. Furthermore, the estimates of spawning biomass and of the impact of coastal fishing used in eel management today should be independently reviewed and revised.
- Time for smarter and safer chemical management
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
– grouping and mixture risk assessment in European chemicals legislation. June 2020: Today’s massive flow of chemicals places new demands on risk management. Managing chemicals in groups and introducing mixture risk assessments into all chemicals legislation are two key measures to protect health and the environment. RECOMMENDATIONS • Establish consistent requirements for mixture risk assessments in all pieces of chemical legislation. Without such requirements, effective protection against risks from exposure to mixtures will not occur. • Establish crosscutting European legislation on chemical pollution with a focus on mixture risks. Chemical mixtures cannot be fully evaluated and managed by sectorial pieces of legislation. • Strengthen the mandate in REACH to manage groups of chemicals to avoid regrettable substitution. Grouping will also contribute to increase efficiency and to reduce mixture risks. • Improve mixture risk assessment and grouping of substances in the context of European water management. The directive is recipient-oriented and in principle should be able identify and undertake measures against chemical pollution created by chemical mixtures. Organisms in the environment are not exposed to single substances in isolation but to complex mixtures of chemicals from numerous sources over the course of their lives. The science is clear – the risk associated with a chemical mixture exceeds the risk of each individual chemical in the mixture. Therefore, assessing and managing each chemical in isolation is insufficient. Organising chemicals into well-defined groups helps to reduce the complexity of chemical risk assessment and management. In order to ensure a high level of environmental protection, European legislation must address two crucial aspects of the regulatory system for chemicals control, namely mixtures and grouping of chemicals.
- Emerging ocean acidification threatens Baltic Sea ecosystems
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
March 2020: More jellyfish but fewer mussels – the expected spread of ocean acidification can have major effects on species composition in the Baltic Sea. It may also make the water slimier and less attractive for swimming. To protect unique ecosystems and future food production, carbon dioxide emissions must be dramatically reduced and measures must be taken against eutrophication, overfishing and releases of hazardous substances. RECOMMENDATIONS To minimise the consequences of ocean acidification, work towards implementing more stringent carbon dioxide emission goals (as per Sustainable Development Goal 14.3). Expand the acidification measurement programmes to include both open sea and coastal waters. High-quality and cohesively longer time series for all parts of the year and in all parts of the Baltic Sea will give a more comprehensive basis for deciding on measures. Accelerate measures against problems such as eutrophication, overfishing and emissions of hazardous substances. Many species can tolerate water that is more acidic. However, their resistance and resilience to stress is diminishing. Coordinate controls and measures against the above-mentioned problems. To strengthen the Baltic Sea’s resistance to future acidification, a marine environment perspective needs to be integrated into land management measures. To promote the development of low-sulphur fuels, investigate a prohibition on emitting scrubber system water from vessels. Widen the support for research into how acidification is affecting ecosystems in the Baltic Sea.
- For cod’s sake – cut back fishing on herring and sprat
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
2019.10.08: In the negotiations for next year’s fishing in the Baltic Sea,the EU Member States could take a number of important decisions to address the cod crisis, such as major reductions in quotas for catches of flatfish, herring and sprat in the southern Baltic.
- Baltic Sea Centre reply to EU consultation on the Communication Sustainable fishing
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
This submission from the Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre focuses on conditions in the Baltic Sea. For references, see below.
- Baltic Sea Centre's comments on the proposed European Oceans Pact
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre replies to the public consultation on the new European Oceans Pact.
- Analysis of the new Nature restoration regulation - from a marine perspective
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The EU Nature Restoration Regulation was adopted in June 2024, with a narrow majority in a vote in the Council of the EU. The Baltic Sea Centre's policy analysts gives their reflections on the regulation from a marine perspective.
- Feedback to the EU Commission proposal to amend the Baltic MAP
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Comments on the proposed change in article 4.6 in in the multiannual plan (MAP) for Baltic Sea fisheries. These comments have been prepared by Charles Berkow, Policy Analyst, and Henrik Svedäng, Associate Professor and Researcher, on behalf of Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre, 30 January 2024. The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre’s comments below refer primarily to the proposal to amend the Baltic MAP . They are to a large extent also relevant for the other MAPs. Summary The Commission proposal should be withdrawn. It is faulty in content and the process leading up to the proposal was deficient. The Commission proposal would increase the level of risk permitted by the MAP. The Commission justification for the weakening of the MAP is based on a misunderstanding of the science and of the structure of the MAP. The MAP, as implemented, has major deficiencies. These should be urgently remedied. A proposal to increase risk Deletion of Art. 4.6, with no compensating measures, removes a safeguard and increases the level of risk in management of Baltic fisheries. It allows the Council to decide on TACs with a high probability of SSB falling below Blim, as the October 2023 Council did when, disregarding Art. 4.6, it set a TACs for two herring stocks with a probability of SSB falling below Blim next year of over 20% - more than four times the risk level than the MAP currently allows. This is not compatible with the objective of stronger stocks in Art 3.1 in the MAP regulation and in Art. 2.2 in the CFP regulation. Failure to meet MAP objectives Most of the fish stocks covered by the MAP in the Baltic have declined since its adoption, contrary to the objectives in the MAP and CFP. This is the reason why Art. 4.6 has come into focus. The development of fish stocks is dependent on a number of factors, both internal and external to management. To the extent that environmental factors contribute to the decline of fish stocks it is important that management, if possible, counteracts these rather than making it worse and applies a more precautionary rather than a riskier approach. Declining environmental conditions are reasons to reduce fishing pressure below present uncertain estimates of levels around MSY. Further, the environmental objective of the MAP (Art. 3.3) and the CFP (Art.2.3) appears to be completely ignored when implementing the MAP, underlining the risk-prone acceptance in management. The MAP, as implemented, has major deficiencies. These need to be urgently remedied. An opportunity to start is the report on the results and impact of the MAP required in July 2024 under Article 15 of the MAP. A misunderstanding of the science and the MAP The Commission’s justification for its proposal is based on a misunderstanding of the science. The Commission has also confused the remedial measures to be taken under Article 5 to be substitutes to the provisions for setting fishing opportunities under Art. 4, instead of supplements. This is explained in more detail here: ANALYSIS: Weakening the management of Baltic fisheries Faulty process We disagree with the COM conclusion in its proposal that no proper public consultation or impact analysis is necessary. This consultation itself is inconsistent with that contention. Further, the socio-economic arguments mentioned appear to only consider the immediate short-term (the following fishing year). The Commission has not assessed the medium- and long-term socio-economic consequences or the environmental consequences of this increased risk level. The process of preparing this proposal is difficult to reconcile with the Interinstitutional Agreement on better law-making. This is explained in more detail here: ANALYSIS: Forgetting the deal Revising the MAP Any revision of the MAP needs clearer definitions (so that e.g. herring caught in fish-meal fisheries is not classed as a “by-catch”) as well as substantially more precise and precautionary rules.
- Response to the EU Commission's Proposal for a Directive on Soil Monitoring and Resilience
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Stockholm University has been asked by the Swedish Ministry of Climate and Enterprises to submit its views on the European Commission's Proposal for a Directive on Soil Monitoring and Resilience. Like the proposal, the University's opinion is written in English. This response has been prepared November 2023, by: PhD Benoit Dessirier, Baltic Sea Centre Gun Rudquist, Head of Policy, Baltic Sea Centre Associate Professor Stefano Manzoni, Department of Physical Geography Introduction Stockholm University is overall supportive of the proposal to establish a regulatory framework for soils. As stated in the proposal, a number of international as well as EU initiatives state that such a framework shall be established, for instance the three Rio Conventions (desertification, climate and biodiversity) and the EU Green Deal Biodiversity Strategy. Healthy soils are a necessity for sustainable development. The University welcomes the fact that a number of EU institutions already have welcomed this initiative. It is of outmost importance that the proposal is being decided on before the upcoming EU election in June 2024, since otherwise the process of getting a soil legislation in place could be severely delayed. At the national level, the University notes with surprise that the Swedish government already formed a position presented at the latest AgriFish meeting, even though the deadline for its open consultation is yet not passed. The proposal, including Annexes, is only including aspects of nutrient leakage to a limited extent. Since there is a strong linkage between soil quality and risk of nutrient leakage to surrounding waters and hence eutrophication, future soil policies should embrace the following. Good soil structure is crucial for minimising surface run off of phosphorus. Legacy of phosphorus in the soils is a major source for external input to water. For instance, in the Baltic Sea region, research shows that almost half of the phosphorus currently entering the Baltic Sea could derive from a pool of accumulated phosphorus on land (McCrackin et al. 2018). The role of legacy P and the properties, fate and management of soil nutrient inventories, have to be considered in a future soil law. In order to reduce the risk of nutrient leakage from soils, manure has to be handled more effectively. The conditions of the soils influence manure management. The role of manure for improved soil structure should be reflected in the proposal. Reduction of nutrient sources from soils can have clear advantages for water quality, but there are trade-offs to be considered. For example, nitrogen additions have the potential to reduce carbon dioxide emissions and increase carbon storage (Janssens et al., 2010). Therefore, the cycling of carbon and nutrients should be monitored and considered together for effective soil management. Soil carbon stabilization (and associated nutrient retention) can be promoted by improving soil structure (e.g., no tillage) and increasing the diversity of residue inputs to soil (e.g., crop rotations, diversified agriculture, cover crops) (Lehmann et al., 2020). Soil condition, nutrient leakage and climate Soil condition and hence nutrient leakage, links to the impact of marine ecosystems on the climate. A marine ecosystem binds carbon in the vegetation and the sediments, but also releases methane. The ratio between carbon sinks or methane sources is dependent on the level of eutrophication of the waters. The more eutrophied, the higher is the risk of marine waters becoming sources of greenhouse gases. The EU Commission proposal does not include this aspect in its proposal. Chemicals Stockholm University supports the inclusion of chemical issues in the proposal. One important part of this complex issue is the impact from sewage sludge on soils. Due to present sewage systems, sludge holds high levels of for instance heavy metals and organic pollutants. Spreading of sewage sludge on soils can therefore lead to accumulation of chemical pollutants in both soils and crops, as well as accumulation of microplastics in soils, which may further leak to the aquatic environment, including groundwater. A future soil law must therefore be made coherent with a revised sewage sludge. More specific comments Article 3, p. 31, (3) “‘ecosystem services’ means indirect contributions of ecosystems to the economic, social, cultural and other benefits that people derive from those ecosystems;”. Comment: Stockholm University wonders why only “indirect contributions” and not also “direct” ones. Here the definition is general, not only ecosystem services associated with soils, so direct contributions might be included. For soils, contributions are probably mostly indirect. Annex I: “Loss of soil organic carbon” is measured in terms of soil organic carbon concentration (g of carbon per kg of soil). Comment: The amount of organic carbon should be expressed in g of carbon per unit ground area (i.e., a stock, not a concentration). The carbon stock is obtained by multiplying concentration by soil bulk density and by the thickness of the sampled soil layer. Since bulk density should be measured as an indicator of soil compaction, this calculation would be easily implemented. This measure accounts for variations in soil density. For example, for a given carbon concentration, soils becoming compacted will have more carbon in a given sampling depth just because their mass per unit volume has increased. Annex I: “Loss of soil biodiversity” is measured as oxygen consumption rate. Comment: Rates of oxygen consumption depend on many factors independent of biodiversity, such as organic carbon concentration, temperature, and to some degree soil texture. Even standardizing the oxygen consumption measurement (e.g., specifying soil moisture during the measurement, pre-incubation durations etc.), Stockholm University wonders how results can be compared across soils in given Member State. Annex I: “The estimated value for the total water holding capacity of a soil district by river basin or subbasin is above the minimal threshold.” Comment: Soil texture and this water holding capacity change in space over short distances, so Stockholm University is not sure how Member States would calculate this parameter for entire river basins. At the very least, basin-scale values should be obtained by averaging soil samples representative of the range of textures in that basin. Methods described in P8 of Annex I regarding estimation of water holding capacity over entire basins are not clear. Overall comment on Annex I It is not clear at which depth(s) soil samples are supposed to be taken, or whether sampling depth should be determined based on fixed layer thickness or by soil horizon. In the literature it is also recognized that changes in soil carbon in the topsoil can be mirrored by opposite changes in the subsoil (e.g., after conversion of cropland to grassland). Therefore, focusing on top soil carbon will give a biased picture of whole profile carbon changes.
- Response to the European Commission proposal for a recast Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Stockholm University Department of Environmental Science’s and Baltic Sea Centre’s response to the European Commission proposal for a recast Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive. This position paper was prepared January 31st 2023, by: Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre • Associate Professor Bo Gustafsson, Director of Baltic Nest Institute • PhD Bärbel Muller Karulis • PhD Benoit Dessirier • Gun Rudquist, Head of Policy • Ellen Bruno, Policy Analyst Stockholm University Department of Environmental Science • Professor Anna Sobek • Professor Christina Rudén • PhD Student Diana Kättström • Professor Ian Cousins • Assistant Professor Marlene Ågerstrand Summary • Overall, Stockholm university Department of Environmental Science and Baltic Sea Centre is supportive of the European Commission proposal for a recast Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive (UWWTD) (26.10.2022, COM(2022) 541 final 2022/0345 (COD). • We support demanding tertiary treatment. From a Baltic Sea perspective, the suggested adaptation time is however unnecessary long since such requirement was decided by Helcom already in 2007. • The definition of “sensitive area” should be expanded to include micropollutants, for instance in relation to limit values for priority substances. • We welcome the inclusion of the Quaternary treatment step into the Directive. Urban wastewater treatment plants are important collection points for many chemical contaminants which are widespread in the aquatic environment. • The list of indicator substances needs to include indicator PFAS. By not doing that the directive seriously risks steering towards techniques that will miss many problematic micropollutants. • We welcome the inclusion of an extended producer responsibility for cosmetics and pharmaceuticals to the Directive. We believe that there is reason to include also the textile industry as many substances in textiles are released during washing and ends up in waste water treatment plants. • Regarding monitoring we welcome the updated requirements for monitoring of priority substances and micro plastics. We welcome that monitoring data will be made available to the Commission and the EEA, but would like to stress that results from monitoring should also be made public. The importance of reducing external load of nutrients to water In recent decades, the nutrient loads to the Baltic Sea have decreased sharply. Eventually, this is expected to lead to improvements in the sea, but because large amounts of nutrients are stored in the water and on land, it will take time to see the effects. In order to comply with the commitments in the Baltic Sea Action Plan (BSAP), and simultaneously improve the environment in lakes and watercourses, the countries around the Baltic Sea need to continue to take measures to further reduce nutrient loads from land. Expanded urban waste water treatment is key. A recent conservative estimate from HELCOM (2022) indicates that phosphorus inputs to the Baltic Sea could readily be reduced by 5-10% if WWTPs complied with treatment levels similar as suggested in proposal. The importance of including micro pollutants treatment to waste water treatment plants Micropollutants have many different sources and transport pathways to lakes and sea, one of the most important ones being urban wastewater treatment plants (UWWTPs). These function as collection points for many of the micropollutants that are diffusely emitted in urban environments. Although primarily designed to reduce levels of nutrients and organic matter, conventional treatment plants also lower the concentration of several but not all micropollutants . Unfortunately, conventional treatment is ineffective in particular for mobile and persistent substances, i.e. highly water-soluble compounds that do not attach to particles and are resistant to biodegradation. Short-chain perfluoroalkyl acids (PFASs) are examples of such substances. Other substances that do not easily degrade in conventional treatment plants and are found in liquid effluents or sludge, are pharmaceutical substances. Removal efficiencies however vary for different pharmaceutical substances due to different chemical and physical characteristics and to operational conditions of the treatment plants. There is increasing evidence that chemical pressure on European water by the small fraction of micropollutants that are currently being monitored are likely having negative effects on aquatic organisms. Hence, including treatment of micropollutants into urban wastewater treatment plants, as suggested in the proposal for updated UWWTD, is of uttermost importance. Detailed comments from Stockholm University researchers on the suggested articles Definition of micropollutants, Art 2 (16) We believe that this definition is important and hence must include as many problematic substances as possible. We believe that the current definition fulfils this requirement as it refers to the CLP-regulation and Part 3 and 4 of Annex I, which include those substances that are hazardous to health and/or the environment. We would also like to emphasize the importance of using “CAN be considered hazardous.” We would, however, like to point to the fact that many substances that are not hazardous on their own at environmental concentrations, may become toxic in mixtures. This effect is not included in the definition. For an even more precautionary approach, micropollutants could be defined as any substances found in the recipient at levels above what can be expected in an unaffected environment. Collecting systems, Art 3 We support all the suggestion for agglomerations with a p.e. of 2000 and above. Individual systems, Art 4 In general, the inclusion of individual systems in the UWWTD is very important and we support this article but would like to underline the following. When implementing the revised UWWTD it is important to consider that the environmental benefits of upgrading or replacing individual systems with connection to waste water treatment plants strongly depend on local hydrological conditions. Drainage pathways and potential retention, influenced e.g. by the surrounding topography, vegetation and soil characteristics, can entail vastly different levels of risk to receiving water bodies. In order to combat eutrophication, individual system in areas with low retention/high leakage risk, draining to lakes and coastal waters with limited water turnover and high nutrient sensitivity, should be given high priority. In individual systems, from a eutrophication perspective, focus should be on ensuring that toilet waste is properly treated. Less effort can be put on grey water (i.e. water from showers, dishing etc) because it does not contain much nutrients. Integrated Urban Wastewater management plans, Art 5, Annex V We support the establishment of integrated urban waste water plans, but it should be done quicker. In Annex 5.C, measures increasing green infrastructures such as wetlands should be included and prioritized because they serve as treatment for both nutrients and micropollutants. Secondary treatment, Art 6 We support increasing secondary treatment. Regarding the monitoring/measurements of discharges (Table 1. in Annex 1); the proposal only suggests measuring BOD. We argue that nutrients (Tot-N and Tot-P) must be included in monitoring, at least for areas identified as sensitive in Annex II. HELCOM also uses the suggested BOD and requires a 70% reduction for P for all secondary treatment and 30% for N in N-sensitive areas. Tertiary treatment, Art 7 We strongly support demanding tertiary treatment. It is an important and effective technique that is already in practice. However, from a Baltic Sea perspective, the suggested adaptation time for Member States is far too long since the HELCOM contracting parties agreed in 2007 to upgrade WWTPs according to similar standards as proposed here. 7.2 suggests establishing a list of areas sensitive to eutrophication. These do already exist as part of for instance the nitrates directive. Therefore, actions can be taken much faster than suggested. The definition of “sensitive area” should be expanded to include micropollutants, for instance in relation to limit values for priority substances. Expanding the scope of the meaning of sensitive areas and conditions for emitting wastewater in these areas under the UWWTD would enable directive contribute to reaching targets set under both the WFD and MSFD. Annex 2, Art 2 describes the procedure of selecting the target nutrient(s) for tertiary treatment. The selection procedure is vague and seems to apply only for WWTPs serving between 10 000 and 1000 000 p.e., leaving the procedure for selecting nutrients to remove for WWTPs serving > 100 000 p.e. unclear. Quaternary treatment, Art 8 We very much welcome the inclusion of the Quaternary treatment step into the Directive. Urban wastewater treatment plants are important collection points for many chemical contaminants which are widespread in the aquatic environment. The Water Framework Directive (WFD) and the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD) set requirements for defining and assessing the status of European fresh and marine waters, and UWWTD is specifically mentioned in these directives as a measure to achieve good ecological and environmental status. We hence welcome the linkage between requirement for treatment with environmental statutes of the recipient for plants between 10 and 100 000 p.e. List of Indicator substances to be removed by at least 80%, Annex 1, Table 3 The list of indicator substances needs to include some indicator PFAS (e.g., perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS), perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA), and perfluorobutane sulfonates (PFBS)), which are common legacy and replacement PFAS representing a range of perfluoroalkyl chain lengths (short and long chains) and thus partitioning behavior. By not including PFAS the directive seriously risks steering towards techniques that will miss many problematic micropollutants with special/unusual partitioning behavior. Many studies show that there is a need for a combination of techniques in order to treat both PFAS and pharmaceuticals in treatment plans. Extended producer responsibility, Art 9 We welcome the inclusion of an extended producer responsibility to the Directive. The Polluter Pay Principle should be a key principle underlying EU environment legislation and policies, as set out in Article 191(2) of the Consolidated Version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (europa.eu). We also understand the rationale behind choosing the cosmetics and pharmaceutical sectors, as all their products and substances will end up in sewage treatment plants. We would however like to argue that there is a case to include also the textile industry as many of the substances used and added to textiles are released during washing and ends up in waste water treatment plants. Notable substances include PFAS, permethrin (insecticide), azo dyes, and phthalates. Energy neutrality of urban waste water treatment plants, Art 11 We support this article, suggesting the establishment on energy audit are carried out. Local climate conditions, Art 13 Art 13 requires UWWTPs to be designed to handle wastewater loads under normal local climatic conditions, but we suggest that climate change, in particular its implications for hydrological extremes, also be considered. Discharges of non-domestic wastewater, Art 14 We welcome that authorities are encouraged to take measures to identify, prevent and reduce as far as possible the sources of pollution in non-domestic wastewater. We also welcome the connection between identified problematic substances through the monitoring system in Art 21, with the possibility for authorities to stop industries wanting to connect to the sewage system. We believe that this upstream approach gives industries incentives to reduce pollutants at the source. Sludge, Art 20 We think that the present sludge directive has little relevance for environmental protection and circular economy and should therefore be revised. A new directive must focus not only on preventing harmful effects on soil, vegetation, animals and people, but also must focus on preventing harmful effects on drinking water, freshwater and the marine environment, by leakage of nutrient, pollutants, pharmaceuticals or microplastics from application of sludge. A new directive should not consider the spread of sludge as the only solution, but should also be open to new techniques that can extract nitrogen and phosphorus and limit the spread of hazardous substances (e.g. heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants), pharmaceuticals and microplastics. Untreated sludge should never be allowed to be spread on agricultural land, not even if it is injected or incorporated into the soil. Monitoring of substances, Art 21 Monitoring of the influx of N and P loads must be included in Table 1 in Annex 1. We welcome the updated requirements for monitoring of priority substances and micro plastics and the established connection to the WFD Daughter Directives. There is a risk of solely relying on lists of priority compounds for monitoring as it will miss the large majority of chemicals in commerce as well as potential mixture effects on aquatic life. Use of chemical screenings that take account of a wide range of pollutants is therefore an important complement, as is effect screening and mixture toxicity assessments based on a wide range of analysed chemicals. Reporting of monitoring results, Art 22 We welcome that datasets with results from monitoring will be made available to the Commission and the EEA, but would like to stress, not the least in the interest of research, that results from monitoring should also be made public. Read this position paper as a Pdf Response to the European Commission proposal for a recast Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive (144 Kb)
- Position paper on the European Commission proposal for an EU regulation on nature restoration
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Proposal for an EU nature restauration regulation much needed to fill shortcomings of the Habitats Directive, the Birds Directive, the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the Water Framework Directive. In June 2022 the European Commission adopted a proposal for an EU regulation on nature restoration. The proposed regulation establishes a framework for Member States to put in place restoration measures covering at least 20% of the EU’s land and sea areas by 2030 and all ecosystems in need of restoration by 2050. Restoration measures are also to be put in place to re-establish and improve the quality and connectivity of habitats and species protected by the Habitats Directive and the Birds Directive (2009/147/EC). In addition, the regulation sets out a series of targets for ecosystems beyond those covered by the Birds and Habitats Directives including those related to urban, river, agricultural and forest ecosystems and to pollinator populations. Researchers at Stockholm University very much welcomes the initiative as it addresses the acute loss of biodiversity within the Union and counterpart the shortcomings of the Habitats Directive, the Birds Directive, the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the Water Framework Directive. Researchers are however questioning whether the 2050 target is sufficient given the urgent need to halt biodiversity loss. Stockholm University believes that the quantitative target should be raised from 20 % to 30 %, to be consistent with and enable the achievement of the EU Biodiversity Strategy targets. Considering that many species continue to decline and are threatened despite current legislation, researchers would also like to see restoration measures cover all species classified as critically endangered and acutely endangered by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). Read the whole Stockholm University Paper on the European Commission proposal for an EU regulation on nature restoration (156 Kb) Read the European Commission's Proposal for a Nature Restoration Law
- The European Commission’s Call for Evidence on the energy transition of EU fisheries and aquaculture
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre's reply to the European Commission’s Call for Evidence on the energy transition of EU fisheries and aquaculture sector: The Baltic Sea Centre submits the following comments. The answer has been prepared by Charles Berkow, Senior Policy Analyst Dec 1, 2022 Summary Fuel subsidies in the form of tax exemptions or reductions are a barrier to implementation of better energy technologies and practices. Important synergies between removal of fuel subsidies, the energy transition and a healthier marine environment should be exploited. More robust fish stocks make for more efficient use of energy in fishing and thereby contribute to the energy transition. Subsidies A key financial and governance barrier that hinders the uptake of technologies and practices necessary to reduce the climate impact of fisheries are the subsidies to fisheries, in particular the exemption from full carbon pricing via taxes or emission trading rights. This makes all other measures less efficient and less effective. Fuel subsidies reduce incentives to invest in more efficient engines or use less fuel-intensive practices. It is inefficient to try to solve problems caused by subsidies with more subsidies. The Commission has proposed a much lower tax for the fisheries sector than other sectors in the Energy Tax Directive. The consequence would be a continued massive subsidy to fishing. When a revised ETD requires unanimity, it may fall. Therefore, inclusion of fisheries in the emissions trading system should be prepared as an alternative. Purchases of fuel outside the EU by vessels with quota to fish in EU waters are in effect imports of fuel to the EU and should be taxed as such. There may be a risk that EU fishers who pay a full carbon price will be outcompeted in the European market by fishers from third countries. If so, protection under the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism should be extended to the fishing sector. In a market economy, economic crises are a corrective to overcapacity such as has plagued fishing. By repeatedly responding to crises with subsidies, the EU sets an important market mechanism out of force. Short-term crisis measures must be combined with compensatory measures, or goal achievement will be delayed. Thus, the latest emergency support should have gone hand in hand with effective measures to reduce overcapacity. Fuel subsidies contribute to the overcapacity that the Commission has identified as a core contributor to problems of European fisheries, including poor profitability and lax compliance, depleted stocks and degraded marine environments. Subsidies such as fuel tax exemptions have been therefore been classified as “harmful” ( Skerritt, Sumaila 2021 ). Failure to account for the decreased natural carbon sequestration caused by fishing can is in effect also a subsidy ( Martin et al 2021 ). Efficiency Efficiency in energy use is a key aspect of the energy transition. Methods such as bottom trawling tend to be less energy efficient than others ( Sala et al 2022 ). Larger fish stocks require less energy to catch a given amount of fish than do more depleted stocks. Therefore, an efficient energy transition requires that the EU achieves the objective of progressively restoring and maintaining populations of fish stocks above biomass levels capable of producing MSY as mandated by Article 2.2 of CFP Regulation. The EU should not “achieve “the objective by reinterpreting “biomass levels capable of producing maximum sustainable yield” as Btrigger or some other target significantly lower than BMSY. If it is not possible to reliably estimate BMSY a more suitable proxy such as 2 x Bpa should be used ( Froese et al 2016 ). Reducing fishing pressure to levels consistent with the environmental objectives of the CFP would further increase energy efficiency. The Commission should routinely request ICES to provide advice on the likely impact of such limitations on the catch as may be required to achieve environmental objectives such as biodiversity (including genetic diversity within the target stock), habitat integrity and foodwebs, under the Specific Grant Agreement between the European Union and ICES.
- Comment on the EC consultation fishing 2023
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Explanatory note – Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre’s comments on European Commission’s Communication Towards more sustainable fishing in the EU: state of play and orientations for 2023. This consultation has been prepared by Charles Berkow, Senior Policy Analyst with contribution by Henrik Svedäng On behalf of Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre April 22, 2022 1. Introduction Since the adoption of the multiannual plan for the Baltic Sea in 2016 (MAP), three of the eight stocks covered by the plan have basically collapsed. A fourth stock, the central Baltic herring, has suffered a major decline with clear indications of regional severe depletions. A fifth stock, Bothnian herring, appears to be affected by a significant regional decline of large herring most attractive for human consumption. The Commission writes that in the Baltic Sea, “the positive trend in recent years has reversed due to the dire environmental situation and past overfishing. This has led to a habitat loss for a number of fish stocks, to decreases in the amount of fish in the sea and to smaller sizes for Baltic cod and now also other Baltic stocks.” While environmental conditions are indeed an important part of the explanation of the situation, in particular for the eastern Baltic cod, the role of single species fisheries management for the development of other stocks cannot be ignored. A key problem is an over-emphasis on trying to achieve a narrowly defined Maximum Sustainable Yield for single stocks, with little or no consideration of its environmental limitations or interrelationships. Important information is not considered, or not included, or not highlighted in the scientific advice used as the basis for decision-making. 2. Progress in achieving sustainable fishing in the EU Included in the objectives of the CFP is to implement an ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management so as to ensure that negative impacts of fishing activities on the marine ecosystem are minimised and avoid the degradation of the environment. In particular, fisheries policy should contribute to achieving the objective of Good Environmental Status under the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD). A natural first step towards achieving this goal would be to take consideration of predator-prey relations between commercial species when deciding on both TACs and technical measures. However, this does not appear to be the case. For example, a key explanation for the decline of the eastern Baltic cod is likely to be food quality changes.(1) This might in turn be due to a decline of the key prey species herring in areas where the cod still exist. This relationship could be taken into consideration when determining regulations TACs and spatial regulations for fishing herring. Descriptors of Good Environmental Status in the MSFD can, in lieu of better information, serve as a proxy for ecosystem considerations. Besides commercial fish and shellfish, these include Biodiversity, Food webs and Sea-floor integrity. During the past years and in particular this summer, the lack of large herring in the Bothnian sea has received attention. This deficit is now resulting in the closure of factories dependent on large fish suitable for production of fermented herring. In a recent document, the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences (SLU) states that fishing according to the current MSY target often leads to a changed size structure, where the share of large fish is decreased. SLU further states that the question of the size structure of the stock is neither requested by the EU nor managed by ICES in the ongoing scientific advice despite the adoption of the MSFD in 2008. SLU concludes that the most effective way to recover a higher share of large herring in the stock is to reduce the fisheries mortality, that is, reduce TACs.(2) Although ICES does provide some indications of some of the issues that might give a more nuanced approach than the current focus on narrowly calculated MSY, these qualifiers are often “buried in the fine print” and easy to miss by decision-makers used to focusing on the headlines. For example, the graphs showing the retrospective analyses provide some indication on the historical uncertainty of the advice. But these graphs are not clearly explained, nor are the consequences.(3) Further, when biomass measured in SSB does not increase despite catches being limited to estimated Fmsy (such as has often been the case for Bothnian herring), this indicates that something is seriously wrong in the calculations and/or the system. This is crucial information that ICES could and should highlight. ICES advice would be more helpful for managers and contribute better to healthy fish stocks for the benefit of both the environment, the fishing sector and coastal communities if it would answer questions like: - What factors, that could be relevant for managers has ICES not taken into account when preparing its advice? E.g. o The impact of fishing this stock on other associated commercially fished stock o The impact of fishing this stock on other associated species e.g. in the food web o The impact of fishing this stock on sea-floor integrity o Impacts on sub-populations or stock components, i.e. threating long lasting reductions in production level and possibly reducing biodiversity o Impacts on the age and size structure of the stock, i.e less valuable catches, changes in ecosystem function, possible evolutionary responses o If the condition of the stock seems to be improving or declining o The consequences of the dominance of a relatively strong year class, and the impact of fishing it or leaving it in the water o Uncertainties due to with the quality of the data, e.g. misreporting of species or of stocks (i.e. if herring caught on a particular voyage is caught in the Bothnian Sea, or the Central Baltic) o Signs of density dependence resulting in impaired growth rates o The general degree of uncertainty in the assessment, e.g. due to changing environmental factors or evidenced by SSB not increasing despite fishing at or below estimated Fmsy. - For each factor, would consideration of this factor be likely to lead to a higher or lower TAC than basing a TAC proposal on the current standard calculation of Fmsy and not taking this factor into consideration? With the exception of density dependence, each of these factors, if given adequate consideration, would likely result in lower removals of fish. Failure to consider such factors, together with an effort to achieve maximum sustainable yield is very risky approach, likely to lead to overshoot. It can take years to rebuild a stock after depletion. Giving adequate consideration to uncertainty would lead to lower catch rates. It should be feasible for ICES to provide the information mentioned above in a transparent and clear manner. This can in turn help to correct the misguided impression that some decision-makers seem to have, that simply following the ICES headline advice on TACs will lead to sustainable fishing. It would thereby improve the potential for achieving the objectives of the CFP and reduce the risks for negative spirals such as have been experienced in the Baltic since the adoption of the MAP. The Commission should consider requesting ICES to provide such information. This would be a way of approaching the target of fishing at 50% of MSY as proposed by e.g. Sidney Holt during the preparation of the Baltic MAP.(4) 3. State of the EU fleet In section 3, the commission describes the situation regarding overcapacity and the action plans Member States are to adopt to deal with it. At the same time, as the Commission highlights in section 3, Member States have not been willing or able enough to deal with the problem. The current measures of capacity, gross tonnage and engine power, in all probability give an overly optimistic view of the situation. They do not take into consideration “technological creep”, the incremental increase in the actual capacity to catch fish due to technical innovations. The Commission has previously estimated this as about 2-3 per cent per year on average. This may be even more in segments where there is considerable new investment in more modern, efficient and effective vessels. Measures of capacity need to be updated. Further, the national level, or an aggregation of national reports, are not necessarily adequate to assess overcapacity in a region such as the Baltic Sea. Regional considerations should be included in the estimation of fleet capacity, ensuring a viable basis for regional fisheries. The Commission could be more active in using the tools at its disposal (such as reporting guidelines). It is also urgently important to come to terms with counterproductive policies such as harmful subsidies on fuel. 4. Economic performance and harmful fuel subsidies Capacity-enhancing subsidies counteract efforts to come to terms with overcapacity. They are harmful when they help a fishing fleet or a vessel catch more fish and reach a better financial result than they would have in the absence of these subsidies.(5) This is also part of the background to the target 14.6 in the Sustainable Development Goals adopted by the United Nations.(6) A main capacity-enhancing subsidy in EU fisheries is the fisheries sector’s exemption from fuel taxes. It is important that the fisheries sector has the same price for carbon emissions as other sectors, whether this is achieved through a revision of the Energy Tax Directive or the Emissions Trading Directive. Progress on this is slow. In contrast, the EU was very quick to introduce a new fuel subsidy in response to the fuel price increases following the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This is a step in the wrong direction. Although a hasty and uncontrolled fleet reduction can cause problems, given the lack of progress on efforts to reduce overcapacity these efforts need to be intensified even more to counteract the negative effects of the new subsidy. Summary • A key cause of the disastrous development of fishing stocks in the Baltic Sea is an over-emphasis on trying to achieve a narrowly defined Maximum Sustainable Yield for single stocks, with little or no consideration of its environmental limitations or interrelationships. Important information is not considered, or not included, or not highlighted in the scientific advice used as the basis for decision-making. • ICES advice would be more helpful for managers and contribute better to healthy fish stocks for the benefit of both the environment, the fishing sector and coastal communities if it would answer questions like: o What factors, that could be relevant for managers has ICES not taken into account when preparing its advice? o For each factor, would consideration of this factor would further uncertainty be acknowledged, pointing to the necessity of keeping TAC substantially below what can be estimated from current MSY procedures? The Commission should consider requesting ICES to provide this information in a clear and transparent manner in the advice sheets, highlighting the factors contributing to the uncertainty related to a specific advice. • Measures of fleet capacity need to be updated to reflect the effects of “technological creep” and the Commission should more actively use the tools at its disposal to reduce overcapacity. Regional considerations should be included in the estimation of fleet capacity, ensuring a viable basis for regional fisheries. • Exemptions from fuel taxes are a particularly harmful subsidy that contributes to overcapacity and excess fishing pressure, damages the marine environment and increase climate-heating emissions. The fishing sector should pay the same price for climate emissions as other sectors. Henrik Svedäng has contributed to this response to the consultation. On behalf of Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre Charles Berkow Policy Analyst
- Comments on the EC's Sustainable Products Initiative
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre's comments on the European Commission’s EU Public consultation on "Sustainable Products Initiative". The Sustainable Products Initiative will revise the Ecodesign Directive and propose additional legislative measures as appropriate, and it aims to make products placed on the EU market more sustainable. This is Stockholm University's additional reply to the European Commission's consultation questionnaire: Today, information on the chemical composition of articles (consumer products) is very scarce, making it difficult to understand which potentially hazardous chemicals are being released to the environment. The lack of chemical ingredient lists also hinders the assessment of human indoor exposure and forms a barrier to implementing a circular economy with non-toxic material cycles. There is an urgent need for standardised methods and legal incentives to increase the availability of information on chemicals in articles for authorities, researchers, and consumers. Please read more in the attached file. Policy brief: Chemicals in articles Comment: Important that Sustainable Products Initiative include transparency on chemicals June 8, 2021
- Comments - Revision of EU legislation on hazard classification, labelling and packaging of chemicals
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre's comments on the European Commission’s Revision of EU legislation on hazard classification, labelling and packaging of chemicals May 31, 2021 The reply concerns this open consultation by the EU Commission. The answer has been prepared by: Marlene Ågerstrand, Assistant Professor, Department of Environmental Science, Stockholm University Marie Löf, PhD, Advocacy and Analysis Officer, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre. We strongly support the ambition in the Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability to " propose new hazard classes and criteria in the CLP Regulation to fully address environmental toxicity, persistency, mobility and bioaccumulation ", by inclusion of PMT and vPvM as new hazard classes.
- Comments on the revision of REACH Regulation to help achieve a toxic-free environment
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre's comments on the European Commission’s Chemicals legislation – revision of REACH Regulation to help achieve a toxic-free environment May 31, 2021 The reply concerns this open consultation by the EU Commission . The answer has been prepared by: Marlene Ågerstrand, Assistant Professor, Department of Environmental Science, Stockholm University Marie Löf, PhD, Advocacy and Analysis Officer, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre. We welcome a careful and limited revision of the EU legislation on registration, evaluation, authorisation and restriction of chemicals, REACH, to better protect humans and the environment against hazardous chemicals and promote a sustainable use of chemicals. It is key, however, that a revision does not lead to a weakened chemicals regulation, in any aspect. A targeted opening of the REACH legislation is therefore needed. Section " Problem the initiative aims to tackle": In general, we agree with the identification of the problems described in the roadmap, which the initiative aims to tackle. However, under the point ‘The evaluation of registration dossiers and substances is too complex and insufficient.’ we find the phrasing ’too complex’ somewhat worrying. It is very important that rationalisations and simplifications of the registration process, incl. the compliance check and substance evaluation, does not lead to a deterioration in the quality of the registration dossiers, or their control, as their completeness and accuracy is a fundament for the risk assessment. Section " Objectives and policy options": Under this section we have identified complementary measures that should be included to improve risk assessment of chemicals: Increasing the transparency of data: Full transparency should be the general rule for the whole chain of events from generation of information, via reporting of data, to hazard and risk assessment. The current developments in the food law are very welcome and should be expanded to all chemicals. In a system where manufacturers are responsible for assessing their own products sufficient resources to control the quality of this work must be secured. The overall aim must be full legal compliance. Making use of academic studies: change the requirements to also include academic studies, if available, in hazard and risk assessment, as a complement to the toxicity studies commissioned by the chemical industry. Increasing the use of academic studies is also expressed in the Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability. Reforming the authorisation process Under ' Reforming the authorisation process' supplement the current wording with text within quotation marks: Reforming the authorisation process: Options include clarifications and simplifications of the current provisions, national authorisation for smaller applications, removing the authorisation title from REACH, integrating the REACH authorisation and restriction systems into one and improving the interface with other pieces of legislation (complementing actions under the one-substance one-assessment action under the Chemicals Strategy), ‘and the concept of essential use should be aligned with the authorisation process’ . We strongly support the ambition in the Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability to ’ introduce endocrine disruptors, persistent, mobile and toxic and very persistent and very mobile substances as categories of substances of very high concern’ within REACH restriction processes. For relevant research and findings that support our ideas, please see the links below: For more information about the need for grouping and mixture risk assessment in European chemicals legislation , please read here: Policy brief - Time for smarter and safer chemical management and here: Future chemical risk management, SOU 2019:45 . For more information about the need for increased transparency in REACH, please read here: Policy brief - European chemicals reglation needs more transparency
- Comments on the policy initiative: Evaluation of the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
The Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre's comments on the European Commission’s EU Public consultation on EU biodiversity policy initiatives. April 4, 2021 The open consultation " Protecting biodiversity: nature restoration targets under EU biodiversity strategy " covers three separate EU biodiversity policy initiatives and the Baltic Sea Centre's reply concern Evaluation of the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020 . Below, you find our additional reply to the consultation questionnaire. Protect nature Many studies and reports show the poor or bad status for species and habitats in the EU, including protected species and habitats. Despite ambitious targets, the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020 has failed to protect species and habitats in the EU, which is our main critique. In the marine environment, protected areas have been significantly expanded since 2011, but unfortunately have not had the intended effect – to protect species and habitats – due to the fact that there are often no or too weak restrictions on which activities that are permitted in these areas. There is a significant amount of activities like commercial fishing, dredging, construction, shipping and boat traffic that occur in Natura2000 areas, which have contributed to the failure to achieve the targets 1 and 4 in the Strategy. The quality of protection is key, relating for instance to what kind of human activities are allowed in the protected area. Management requirements must be strongly incentivized and monitored as per full implementation of the Nature Directives and Marine Directive. All marine protected areas (MPA) are not in need of the same kind of protection, thus the management requirements and restrictions on activities should be adapted to fit the purpose of the MPA. Strict protection will be important to protect sensitive species and/or habitats. In areas with strict protection all potential disturbing activities should be regulated. Also, buffer zones may be needed around strictly protected areas. Recent research from Stockholm University has showed that buffer zones may be important to protect species and/or habitats from sediment resuspension from bottom trawling. Turbidity and sedimentation can have negative effects on e.g. fish, benthic organisms and habitats. Connectivity is another important issue to consider, ensuring that the network of protected areas is functional for the species and habitats it aims to preserve, allowing for movement of individuals and gene flow. Protection should not only be geographically defined but also have temporal dimensions, e.g. taking spawning areas and times for fish into consideration. Environmental considerations in the CFP The European Common fisheries policy (CFP) is a complex balancing act between environmental considerations and socio-economics. In a reform of CFP some years back, the main aim was to reduce the negative impacts of fishing on marine ecosystems caused by excessive and non-selective catches, and the use of fishing methods that have given rise to extensive by-catches and physical damage to the seabed. This would be achieved e.g. through increased coordination between the EU's environmental and fisheries policy, where multi-annual plans and decisions on quotas would be based on the basis of scientific assessments of the impact of fisheries on the entire marine ecosystem. Environmental protection would thus be better integrated into the fisheries policy. However, this pursued coordination of environmental and fisheries policy has largely failed. Even though the reform brought several improvements, important shortcomings remain. Environmental law research shows that the CFP has not been coordinated with the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the Water Framework Directive, which is particularly noteworthy, as these frameworks are comprehensive in the management of marine ecosystems – where fish species often play a key role. Some years after the reform of the CFP, the negative consequences of the lack of coordination between environmental and fisheries policy have now been manifested. Fishing quotas continue to exceed the scientific recommendations, and multi-annual plans do not to a sufficient extent take the connections in the ecosystems and the ecological functions of the species into account. Also, as mentioned above, many marine protected areas lack still lack regulations for fishing. There are several examples of negative consequences of not taking environmental considerations in EU fisheries policy; one example is the continued decline in cod stocks in the Baltic Sea, where the fishing quotas recommended by research have been consistently exceeded. The radical decline in cod stocks has led to fundamental changes in the Baltic Sea ecosystem. If the target for healthy and productive marine environments are to be achieved - and fishing can continue to be pursued in the long term as well - further measures must therefore be taken to improve coordination between the two policy areas as soon as possible. Otherwise, there is a risk that the important ecosystem services that the sea provides, and on which society depends, will be lost.
- Comments on EU Commission combined evaluation roadmap/inception impact assessment of the MSFD
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre summarized comments on EU Commission combined evaluation roadmap/inception impact assessment of the MSFD. 5 May 2021 On behalf of the Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre, Gun Rudquist , Head of Policy gun.rudquist@su.se Charles Berkow , Policy Analyst charles.berkow@su.se Marie Löf , Policy Analyst, marie.lof@su.se Summary • The marine ecosystems are not in good environmental status so a stronger directive is necessary. The BSC has yet not a final view on the best future policy option. • A fundamental problem is that measures need to be taken in other policy areas in order to achieve the goals of the MSFD. In particular the fisheries policy area has failed to deliver despite the explicit connection to the MSFD in the reformed CFP. • In the absence of agreed threshold values for descriptors and criteria a precautionary principle should be applied for sectors such as fisheries whose impacts can delay achievement of good environmental status. • MPAs are an important tool but have no or too weak restrictions on permitted activities. • Areas free of human disturbance are essential reference tools for research. • The cumulative impacts of multiple stress factors on ecosystems and/or species must be taken into regard in marine spatial planning and in management plans for protected areas. • Monitoring should be better designed to enable evaluation of effectiveness of specific measures and temporal trends in emissions of hazardous substances and environmental levels. • In the revision of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive, UWWTD, criteria need to be developed for minimum chemical wastewater quality that address micropollutants and their mixtures and a clear connection must be established to the Marine Strategy Framework Directive. • The connection between the CAP and the MSFD should improve. The need for revision The Baltic Sea Centre fully supports the need to sharpen, better implement etc the directive but has at this moment in the process, no opinion regarding whether or not the MSFD should be repealed, revised fully or only slightly updated. Presently, we limit our comments to the issues below which a revision process should take into account. Regarding problems the initiative aims to tackle; a good, functional protection and management of the marine ecosystems are still lacking. The environmental impact is still putting severe stress on the ecosystems. Species and habitats Many studies and reports show the poor or bad status for species and habitats in the EU, including protected species and habitats. Despite ambitious targets, the EU Biodiversity Strategy to 2020 has failed to protect species and habitats in the EU, which is our main critique. In the marine environment, protected areas have been significantly expanded since 2011, but unfortunately have not had the intended effect – to protect species and habitats – due to the fact that there are often no or too weak restrictions on which activities that are permitted in these areas. There is a significant amount of activities like commercial fishing, dredging, construction, shipping and boat traffic that occur in Natura 2000 areas, which have contributed to the failure to achieve the targets 1 and 4 in the Biodiversity Strategy. The quality of protection is key, relating for instance to what kind of human activities are allowed in the protected area. Management requirements must be strongly incentivised and monitored as per full implementation of the Nature Directives and Marine Directive. All marine protected areas are not in need of the same kind of protection, thus the management requirements and restrictions on activities should be adapted to fit the purpose of the area. Strict protection will be important to protect sensitive species and/or habitats. In areas with strict protection all potential disturbing activities should be regulated. Also, buffer zones may be needed around strictly protected areas. Recent research from Stockholm University has showed that marine buffer zones may be important to protect species and/or habitats from sediment resuspension from bottom trawling. Turbidity and sedimentation can have negative effects on e.g. fish, benthic organisms and habitats. Connectivity is another important issue to consider and improve, ensuring that the network of protected areas is functional for the species and habitats it aims to preserve, allowing for movement of individuals and gene flow. Protection should not only be geographically defined but also have temporal dimensions, e.g. taking spawning areas and times for fish into consideration. Along with the work to protect sensitive environments, there are strong arguments for establishing areas free of any human disturbance in all types of habitats that occur in a region, not only the most sensitive habitats. Firstly, such areas show the natural species composition and biogeochemical processes and can serve as ecological references to study the effects of bottom trawling and other disturbances on the marine environment. Lack of comparable, non-trawled areas has been identified as a major challenge for studies of long- term effects of trawling on benthic communities and seabed biogeochemistry. Secondly, protecting areas representative of different types of marine ecosystems is in line with the precautionary principle of ecosystem-based marine management, providing a refuge for benthic species that can help rebuild populations in impacted areas. The cumulative impacts of multiple stress factors on ecosystems and/or species must be taken into regard in marine spatial planning and in management plans for protected areas. Climate change and ocean acidification constitutes additional stress factors that may increase species sensitivity to other factors. These factors will be difficult to eliminate on shorter time scales, which makes it extra important to take measures to reduce other marine stress factors, such as eutrophication, emissions of hazardous substances including oil spills, use of destructive fishing practices, and deep-sea mining. Intensive shipping routes should not be allowed to pass through protected areas if species or habitats are threathened. We would like to stress the importance of limiting bottom trawling to protect biodiversity, sea bottom integrity, and biogeochemical processes; taking measures to strengthen stocks of predatory fish in coastal areas; introducing ecosystem-based management; and take measures against physical impacts on coastal areas. In strategies and measures aiming at biological recovery in coastal waters and reducing physical impacts, it is key to have an understanding for that land and sea are connected, as ecosystems and in processes. Thus, strategies and measures need to reflect this. Species such as migratory fish must be able to migrate between the sea, coastal waters and inland waters, physical barriers must be removed and all relevant authorities need to be involved in this work. Fisheries Fisheries policy has failed to deliver its contribution to the achievement of good environmental status both for commercially fished stocks and for a number of other indicators. Progress has been disappointing despite the explicit reference to the MSFD in the revised CFP and the reorganization of the Commission so the Commissioner responsible for the CFP is also responsible for the MSFD. The Commission should specifically request ICES to integrate ecosystem considerations relevant to the achievement of the objectives of the MSFD in its advice on fisheries. At present there is not even reference to the size and age structure of the fish stocks (D3C3 in the MSFD) even when this information is available in the ICES working groups. Information included in ICES ecosystem overviews is not integrated into fisheries advice. This lack seriously hampers the ability of fisheries management to implement the ecosystem-based approach as mandated in the Basic Regulation. One reason is the lack of thresholds that were to be established under the Commission implementing decision from 2017 have not been established. However, instead of applying the precautionary approach as mandated by the Basic Regulation, fisheries management has tended to simply ignore the ecosystem-based approach even at the level of considerations of impacts of fishing on associated commercial fisheries. A future implementing decision should make explicit that in the absence of threshold values a precautionary buffer shall be applied to sectors whose impacts can impede achievement of good environmental status. For example, fishing at 80% of MSY would contribute to the improvement of a number of fisheries-related descriptors. This would give an incentive for Member States to actually establish the thresholds as mandated in the current implementing decision. As things stand now, there are in some cases indirect incentives for Member States to not establish such threshold values, as these would make it clearer that the particular aspect of good environmental status is not being achieved. In the presence of indications that descriptors or their criteria are developing in the wrong direction, the precautionary buffer should increase. The Commission should request that ICES integrate these MSFD-relevant ecosystem impacts in its fisheries advice. Hazardous substances Regarding chemical pollution, the MSFD and its POMs would benefit from including more of a source to sea perspective , and a closer connection to the WFD. It is understandable to avoid duplication of measures under various legislation and action programmes under the WFD. The risk with this reasoning, however, is that measures in the water authorities' action programmes have only an inland and coastal perspective, and not also a marine perspective. Since most of the chemical pollutants present in the sea come from activities on land or coast, this means that action on land is most important and that no measures may be needed at all in the marine environment action programme. It is also the case that even for those substances that have sea-based sources, land-based inputs are often dominant. This means that sea-based sources receive unjustifiably high focus as the action programme has to be filled with some measures, i.e. it leads to inefficient actions being prioritised. The indicators for hazardous substances do not cover all problems related to chemical pollution in the sea, i.e. substances covered by the indicators do not represent the wider chemical pollution in the sea and the possible combination effects. Therefore, there is a need to further build up knowledge and develop indicators. Action programmes could for example include knowledge-building measures such as various types of screening activities to identify new environmental toxins, with a specific focus on high-risk chemicals, substances of very high concern, SVHCs (e.g. very persistent and very bioaccumulative chemicals, vPvB; chemcals that are carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic for reproduction, CMR; endocrine- disrupting chemicals, EDCs) In the context of the Zero Pollution Action Plan and MSFD, monitoring should be better designed to enable evaluation of effectiveness of specific measures and temporal trends in emissions of hazardous substances and environmental levels. Currently compiled data under e.g. MSFD, WFD, IED/E-PRTR etc are not appropriate for this evaluation due to differences in monitoring and reporting approaches between nations and also over time. In the revision of the Urban Wastewater Treatment Directive , UWWTD, criteria need to be developed for minimum chemical wastewater quality that address micropollutants and their mixtures. A clear connection must be established to the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the Water Framework Directive (MSFD and WFD) ensuring that the UWWTD functions as a means of also achieving good chemical/ecological/environmental status of surface waters with regard to chemicals of emerging concern and other micropollutants. The connection should allow for flexibility in the definition of good status as science and policy progress. Eutrophication As was stated above in relation to hazardous chemicals, to combat eutrophication actions on land are most important. Measures addressing waste water treatment plants and agriculture are central areas for action. Regarding agriculture, among a number of relevant policy areas, the Common Agricultural Policy, CAP, is of high concern. Presently the programmes and actions in the CAP mainly focus on inland waters and do not consider the marine environment enough. The linkages between CAP and MSFD could be improved.