Brown Bag: Ying Shi (Syracuse University)
Seminar title: Migrant Buslift, Crime, and Voter Behavior: Evidence from New York City's Emergency Shelters
Abstract
The 2021–2024 surge in U.S. border crossings pushed immigration to the center of the national debate. New York City received more than 200,000 migrants, many of whom were bussed from Texas, starting in mid-2022. The city placed many new arrivals through its shelter system and opened new emergency shelters when existing facilities reached capacity.
We assemble a new dataset of these openings and link to NYC police department and 911/311 call data and New York State voter records to study the effect of the migrant influx on local crime and voter behavior. We first corroborate using multiple sources that shelter openings track where migrants were placed. We then link openings incident-level crime data on a fine spatial grid and compare local areas near shelters to control areas slightly farther away.
We find that exposure to migrant shelter openings is accompanied by a rise in disorder and violent incidents that primarily reflect interpersonal conflicts, with increases concentrated among younger Hispanics, both as suspects and victims. We also find an increase in exit from NY voter rolls, particularly among non-Hispanic registered voters. Exposure to new shelters does not appear to affect registered voters’ within-state migration or partisanship.
Last updated: 2026-10-19
Source: Swedish Institute for Social Research