SWS Seminar: Margarita León (Universitat Autònoma Barcelona)
Seminar title: "Guardianship Care: Governing Dependency in Democratic Welfare States"
Abstract
Welfare states routinely assume direct responsibility for populations requiring special protection, including vulnerable children, the elderly and persons with disabilities or mental health conditions. These interventions represent some of the most intrusive exercises of public authority, as they entail direct oversight of people’s lives and confer on public or delegated institutions considerable power over their personal and bodily autonomy. Depending on how this authority is organised, it might restrict individual agency or create the conditions through which it can be exercised. Thus, this type of institutional care occupies a distinctive position at the intersection of individual rights and public authority. I use the term ‘care under state guardianship’ to refer to this form of state power. It is characterised by three conditions: (1) a care or protection rationale in which individual autonomy is particularly at stake; (2) a residential or otherwise enclosed setting, ranging from large institutions to small community-based residential units, typically in the absence of familial or personal ties; and (3) public responsibility for provision, whether the state provides care directly or delegates it to private or third-sector actors.
The project aims is to explain how modern welfare states exercise and justify authority through care, how this authority is historically and geographically organised and contested across institutional contexts and policy domains, and why guardianship care may, under certain conditions, result in institutional abuse while under others might become an enabling and capacitating infrastructure for autonomous living. The project addresses a conceptual and empirical blind spot in the relationship between care and the state: the different forms of guardianship care have rarely been analysed as a distinct modality of state power, in which the imperative to protect coexists with the exercise of authority over dependent populations. It remains a frontier problem within democratic welfare states, where the promise of care without coercion is both most demanding and most fragile, and where political, civil, and social citizenship rights can be most compromised. This tension, which is a foundational problem of political equality in democratic theory (Dahl, 1989; Young, 2000), acquires renewed urgency under democratic backsliding (Bermeo, 2016), as institutions established to protect vulnerable populations may be repurposed towards control and exclusion. If social and care policies always work through institutions (Dahl & Occhino, 2024), guardianship care serves theoretically and empirically as an extreme case (Flyvbjerg, 2006; Yin, 2018) of how transformations in democratic state power are enacted in the everyday governance of ‘dependent’ populations.
Short bio
Margarita León is a Professor of Political Science at the Autonomous University of Barcelona and Director of the Institute of Government and Public Policy (IGOP) of the UAB. Her research focuses on comparative social policy and welfare state research, with a special focus on the political drivers of social policy reform, gender equality and care policy.
Last updated: 2026-10-27
Source: Swedish Institute for Social Research