Baltic Breakfast: Fisheries management in the Baltic Sea – two failed models
Management of fisheries in the Baltic Sea has generally failed to meet its objectives. Two recently published scientific articles dive deeper into the reasons. A new calculation showing a decline in the abundance of eels in northern European coastal waters and calls into question the effectiveness of the decentralized management of eels based on national eel management plans. Another article analyzes serious deficiencies in the EU's centralised management of key commercial fish stocks, such as cod, herring and sprat, and proposes an alternative, more precautionary and ecosystem-based approach.
Seminar
Date:
Wednesday 24 September 2025Time:
08.30 – 09.15Location:
Scandic Klara, Slöjdgatan 7, Stockholm, and digitallyIt is widely acknowledged that fisheries management in the Baltic Sea has not been successful. Some blame deteriorating environmental conditions such as eutrophication, climate change, predation from wild animals or habitat destruction. Others claim that fisheries management should take environmental conditions into consideration and that fisheries management decisions are likely to a quicker impact on fish stocks and the marine environment than measures targeting other environmental issues, as urgent (though lagging) as many of these measures are.
The European eel, while covered by the Common Fisheries Policy, last revised in 2013, is also managed under the broader Eel regulation from 2007, providing for decentralised management under the national eel management programs approved by the European Commission. In annual decisions on eel fishing, the Council of Ministers has for a number of years consistently ignored the scientific advice from the International Council on Exploration of the Sea (ICES). In Sweden, this has sometimes been justified by estimates implying an abundance of eel in the Baltic. New research indicates that these estimates have been exaggerated (supporting ICES’ conclusions) and that eel management needs to be revised. Indeed, eel return migration to the Sargasso Sea is unlikely to have improved over the last decades, since the abundance of larger eel (≥ 50 cm) in northern Europe coastal waters was indicated to be in sharp decline.
The major fish commercial fish stocks in the Baltic (cod, herring and sprat), on the other hand, are more centrally and jointly managed under the Common Fisheries Policy and the Baltic Sea Multiannual Plan (MAP). While previously often setting Total Allowable Catches (TACs) above what scientists have calculated should be sustainable, since the adoption of the MAP in 2016 Ministers have prided themselves for keeping TACs within or close to the ICES forecasts for catches compatible with achieving Maximum Sustainable Yield. Still, results have been disappointing. A new article reveals fundamental flaws in the ICES-Council TAC setting process. An alternative path is proposed, more in line with the mandate of the Common Fisheries Policy to have a precautionary and ecosystem-based approach.
Warm welcome to a seminar presenting these findings and discussing their implications for future policy!
Participants
Henrik Svedäng, Associate Professor in Marine Ecology, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre and Swedish Institute for the Marine Environment (SIME), Gothenburg University, Sweden.
Eva Papaioannou, Scientist, Marine Evolutionary Ecology, GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Division of Marine Ecology–Marine Evolutionary Ecology, Kiel, Germany.
Moderator: Charles Berkow, Policy Analyst, Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre
Practical information
This seminar is held in English.
The seminar is held on Wednesday 24 September 2025, 8:30 – 9:15 am, at Scandic Klara, Slöjdgatan 7 in Stockholm. Breakfast will be served from 8:00 am.
Physical participation requires registration.
The seminar will also be livestreamed at this webpage and at su.se/balticseacentre/balticbreakfast. A recording can be watched afterwards at the same webpage.
About Baltic Breakfast
Baltic Breakfast is a series of short breakfast seminars/webinars organised by Stockholm University Baltic Sea Centre. Their aim is to present the latest knowledge about issues of central importance to the Baltic Sea environment. The webinars are addressed to people in different sectors working for a sustainable development in the Baltic Sea region and everyone interested in environmental issues of the Baltic Sea.
Most Baltic Breakfasts are held in Swedish, but sometimes they are targeted at an international audience and held in English. If you want to get invitations to the upcoming webinars or subscribe to our monthly newsletters, click here.
Last updated: 2025-09-15
Source: Baltic Sea Centre