PhD thesis defence, Daniel Escobar Carbonari
Title: Muddy waters: Managing drained forested peatlands in northern latitudes for climate change mitigation.
Abstract [en]
Northern peatlands have accumulated substantial carbon stocks over millennia, contributing to global atmospheric cooling. However, widespread forestry drainage in countries like Sweden has transformed these landscapes, and the climate consequences of such drained systems are increasingly being questioned. In this thesis, I examine, through system analysis, literature synthesis, process-based ecosystem modelling, and geospatial analyses, whether rewetting drained forested peatlands constitutes an effective climate change mitigation strategy.
Biogeochemical mechanisms controlling greenhouse gas dynamics in peatlands were synthesised through causal loop diagrams, which revealed water table position as the master variable governing oxygen availability, plant productivity, decomposition pathways, and gas transport. Empirical evidence comparing rewetted peatlands with drained forested sites showed that studies were typically short-term (<4 years), and restored carbon sinks required extended time periods after restoration (>10 years) to develop. Additionally, CH4 emissions were highly variable. Most studies have used global warming potential metrics, which are not suited for assessing sustained emission pathways resulting from land-use change. System boundaries varied among studies, with ongoing debate about how to account for carbon in tree biomass. These findings highlighted the need for integrated modelling approaches.
The ForSAFE-Peat model was employed to simulate carbon dynamics across two forest rotations (1951-2088) at a Swedish drained peatland site, successfully reproducing observed water table depths, soil temperatures, and carbon fluxes. The analysis revealed persistent soil carbon losses averaging 252 gC m-2 yr-1. These losses varied substantially across stand development, with the highest carbon losses observed during the early post-drainage and post-harvest stages. Integrated carbon storage metrics accounting for residence time demonstrated that even with a positive net carbon balance when including tree biomass and harvested wood products, the system exerted negative climate impacts due to the temporal distribution of fluxes.
Alternative management trajectories for drained forested peatlands were evaluated across climatic and nutrient gradients for the period 2020–2100, comparing conventional forestry, continuous cover forestry (CCF), and rewetting. For each land-use trajectory, climate forcing contributions from CO2, CH4, N2O, and surface albedo were quantified. The resulting climate impact was expressed as the change in integrated radiative forcing (ΔIRF), representing the total change in global atmospheric energy balance (Wyr m-2earth) per unit area of alternative land-use trajectory (m-2alt).
Rewetting effects ranged from modest cooling under nutrient-rich conditions in the north (-0.8 × 10-12 Wyr m-2earth m-2alt) to modest warming under nutrient-poor conditions in the south (0.9 × 10-12 Wyr m-2earth m-2alt). This outcome reflects the trade-off between effectively reducing soil carbon losses and the sustained CH4 emissions that accompany rewetting. Conversely, CCF exerted a consistently cooling influence across all climatic and nutrient conditions (-4.8 to -1.8 × 10-12 Wyr m-2earth m-2alt) by maintaining forest carbon stocks and reducing soil GHG emissions. However, it should be noted that the model did not include extreme disturbances such as fire or windthrow, which could differentially affect forested versus rewetted open peatlands and potentially alter these conclusions.
Analysis of peat-fire patterns across Sweden (2001-2023) revealed that peat soils burned at least proportionally to their landscape occurrence, with higher representation in fire-affected areas in southern Sweden. Fire-affected peatlands exhibited ditch densities broadly similar to those in non-affected areas, although with a modest tendency toward lower values, suggesting that fire suppression, linked to intensive management, may counteract the enhanced flammability typically associated with drainage.
The thesis concludes that rewetting mature drained forested peatlands has limited potential to mitigate climate change in the upcoming decades, and the CCF is likely a more favourable alternative through preserving current carbon stocks. These findings have important implications for EU restoration targets and suggest prioritising young nutrient-rich stands for rewetting while implementing CCF in mature forests to maximise climate benefits within policy-relevant timeframes.
Opponent
Laudon, Hjalmar, Professor
Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Department of Forest Ecology and Management.
Handledare
Belyazid, Salim, Professor
Stockholm University, Faculty of Science, Department of Physical Geography.
Last updated: 2025-12-17
Source: Department of Physical Geography