Forskarseminarium med Sarah Muir and Jeff Maskovsky från The City University of New York
"Commoning Projects of Ill Repute"
Abstract:
If there are two stories of commoning that have an understandable allure, it is AIDS activism and mutual aid. Both are stories in which those abandoned by state and capital rally to forge alternative forms of being together that refuse to be subordinated to state control and market logics. But there is just enough truth to these stories to make them misleading. Scholarly and popular discourse frequently romanticizes the commons as a realm of moral purity, political respectability, and seamless egalitarianism. Countering this idealized narrative, this paper examines the messy, conflictual, and disreputable dimensions of commoning, emphasizing how actually-existing forms of communal property are made and sustained through illicit, illegal, and morally ambiguous practices. Through a comparative analysis of two distinct cases—Philadelphia AIDS activists expropriating proprietary pharmaceutical data and health care and economically precarious Argentine residents sharing tips within a cryptocurrency scheme—this paper identifies the core antagonisms that drive collective resource-sharing under conditions of marginalization. Across both cases, the lifecycle of the commons unfolds through a distinct three-phase dynamic. First, state failure to secure medical or economic well-being results in the systemic expulsion of vulnerable populations from the broader body politic. Second, those who are expelled unite in experiments of mutual aid to mitigate harm and enhance their welfare and survival. They do this through collective-knowledge sharing and unregulated and informal expropriation and circulation of resources. Third, these emergent commons undergo domestication, as liberal governance mechanisms and market forces gradually regulate, absorb, or commodify their practices. By attending to these complex transitions, this paper highlights the deep ambivalences within the moral economy of commoning. Ultimately, the authors argue that even fleeting, illegal, or morally ambiguous commoning practices provide crucial theoretical and practical frameworks for understanding collective agency, survival strategies, and political resistance in response to institutional failure.
Bio:
Jeff Maskovsky is Professor and Executive Officer (Chair) of the Ph.D. Program in Anthropology at the CUNY Graduate Center, and Professor of Urban Studies at Queens College.
He is currently engaged in two justice- and equality-oriented research projects on the future of commoning, the messy work of cooperating, being together, and sharing resources to defend vulnerable forms of life and to reimagine the world. One considers the ways that race, sex, gender and class politics enclose the urban commons and the things grassroots activists do to try to overcome these enclosures. A second investigates the future of the rural commons and the ways that new forms of scarcity, enclosure, and austerity thinking reorganize them. He has done fieldwork in the city of Philadelphia and in rural areas of northern Spain in pursuit of these projects. He also writes on angry politics and the reactionary right in the United States and worldwide.
He has co-edited three volumes in critical urban studies and American studies — The New Poverty Studies: Ethnographies of Power, Politics and Impoverished People in the United States (NYU Press, 2001), Rethinking America: The Imperial Homeland in the 21st Century (Paradigm Press, 2009) and Beyond Populism: Angry Politics and the Twilight of Neoliberalism (West Virginia University Press, 2020). With Julian Brash, he is currently co-editing the Handbook of Critical Political Economy for De Gruyter Press. His work has appeared in many anthologies and in American Anthropologist, American Quarterly, Annual Review of Anthropology, Antipode, City and Society, Critique of Anthropology, Focaal, Identities, and Medical Anthropology.
He was recently elected president-elect of the American Anthropological Association.
Sarah Muir is Associate Professor of Anthropology and Interdisciplinary Programs at The City College of New York and of Linguistic Anthropology at The Graduate Center of the City University of New York. Her research draws on the traditions of linguistic, political-economic, and historical anthropology to investigate practices of economic investment and ethical evaluation in contemporary Argentina. Her first book, Routine Crisis: An Ethnography of Disillusion (University of Chicago Press, 2021), traces the lived consequences of Argentina’s history of repeated financial crises. Also grounded in Argentina, her second book project, Accounting for Kith and Kin: Financial Ethics and the Space-Time of Obligation (in preparation), tracks the role of economic numbers in the politics of obligation, belonging, and accountability. Her work has appeared in journals such as Annual Review of Anthropology, Comparative Studies in Society and History, Cultural Anthropology, Current Anthropology, Dialogues in Human Geography, Economic Anthropology, Journal of Cultural Economy, Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, Limn, and Review of the Italian Academic Association of Cultural Anthropologists.
Muir is a founding member of a feminist economy working group housed at New York University and co-directed the Unpayable Debt Working Group at Columbia University. She has helped curate and author works of public scholarship such as the Global Debt Syllabus and the Caribbean Debt Syllabus, and she currently serves on the Advisory Board or as Co-PI on research initiatives in the United States, Europe, and Australia concerning emergent questions within the fields of financial technology, investment, and scams. With Jeff Maskovsky, she is co-organizing a Fall 2025 conference in New York City on the politics of abundance and commoning.
Senast uppdaterad: 2026-10-14
Sidansvarig: Socialantropologiska institutionen