Forskarseminarium med Clelia Bartoli från University of Palermo
"The Otherwise Method. A critical-creative process for shifting political practices from manipulation to conviviality"
Abstract:
Manipulation is a hallmark of domination, both in interpersonal relationships and in socio-political ones throughout history. With the rise of surveillance capitalism, this tendency has become more extreme and sophisticated. Teams of neuroscientists and specialists in sociopsychology offer guidance for developing algorithms and platforms that induce addiction and allow unprecedented intrusion into the most intimate sphere, managing to isolate and control, even to the point of orienting elections and sparking clashes and conflicts. This creates a vicious cycle that induces and rewards the manipulative attitude, selecting leaders and establishments with profiles of the so-called "dark triad" (narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathy).
On the other hand, protesters and revolutionaries often fail to consider how much their minds are inhabited by the categories of the contested order, ending up by re-proposing manipulative dynamics within their milieu. Thus, the language of protest is often limited to defining itself by difference, declaring itself "against" and "alternative", producing deep critical analysis but not creative enough.
Clelia Bartoli will present the "Otherwise Method”. She has been working to experiment and pilot it over years with diverse communities, aspiring not only to train unorthodox political thinking but to give rise to convivial institutions and practices. The "manipulation/conviviality" couple of concepts, proposed by Ivan Illich, is developed by the author to rethink the means/ends dialectic, the user/tool relationship, the geometries of power, and the approach to desire.
Bio:
Clelia Bartoli teaches Human Rights, Migration Politics, and Sociology of Law at the Law Department of the University of Palermo, where she coordinates an international master in "Migration and Rights". She has developed an educational approach (Upside-down Academy) that question the power dynamics embedded in the university, using urban and rural locations as educational spaces and including people outside of academia, often marginalized, as co-creators of knowledge. For example, she coordinated an inquiry led by students and sellers of an informal flea market about the law as seen by outlaws. She devised the "Otherwise Method" a collective process to establish unorthodox and convivial institutions. Using this methodology, she has conducted several action-research projects, such as writing a bill for providing support, care and harm reduction for people with addictions. The norms were written by students, people with a background of addiction, their family members, and social workers. The bill became the Law 26/2024 of the Sicilian Region. With a group of young refugees, she created Giocherenda: a collective that invents and organizes cooperative games. She has also conducted ethnographic research on insurgences, including the Dalit movement in India and of the Chilean uprising (2019/2020). Among her books: Teoria della subalternità e il caso dei dalit in India (2008); Razzisti per legge. L’Italia che discrimina (2012); Legal clinics in Europe. For a commitment of higher education in social justice (2016); Inchiesta a Ballarò. Il diritto visto dal margine (2019); Chile Revolts: from the Uprisings Toward the Constitutional Process (2022).
Senast uppdaterad: 2026-04-24
Sidansvarig: Socialantropologiska institutionen