Högre seminarium i praktisk filosofi: Marcel Jahn (Stockholm University)
Political Legitimacy and the Authority of Reasons: Relocating the Value of Democracy
In many countries, citizens feel increasingly alienated from democratic institutions, which they perceive as becoming less responsive to their views, concerns, and needs, despite enjoying formal rights of political participation. This development poses a new challenge to the view that legitimate political authority must be democratic. I argue that the leading accounts of democracy’s legitimating value—non-instrumentalism and epistemic instrumentalism—are ill-equipped to address this problem. As an alternative, I develop a revised version of Joseph Raz’s service conception. In its basic form, it holds that an authority is legitimate insofar as following its directives enables subjects to better conform to the reasons that already apply to them. I supplement this conception with a distinction between what I call generally shared reasons, which apply to virtually all citizens, and position-sensitive reasons, which depend on citizens’ social positions, occupational roles, forms of association, or values. Because political institutions often lack adequate knowledge of position-sensitive reasons, democratic procedures are essential for revealing those reasons and helping institutions respond to them. This account promises to advance theoretical debates on political legitimacy while identifying a potential source of democratic alienation—citizens’ perception that their reasons are systematically overlooked—and suggesting concrete institutional remedies.
Senast uppdaterad: 2026-10-12
Sidansvarig: Filosofiska institutionen