CLLAM seminarium: Rebecca Wallbank (UU)
On the Formation of Verdictive Aesthetic Beliefs
This paper rejects two claims which form an emerging trend in aesthetic discourse. First, that deferential reliance on the aesthetic judgements of others is problematic, whilst reliance upon ourselves is unproblematic (and in fact required for the formation of legitimate aesthetic judgements). Second, that deferential reliance on the aesthetic judgements of others is problematic for reasons which pertain to aesthetic value and not epistemic value. These claims fail to be true for at least some kinds of aesthetic judgements – in particular, verdictive aesthetic judgements. Contrary to increasingly popular opinion: (i) deferential reliance on others for verdictive aesthetic judgementsis epistemically problematic in important overlooked ways, whilst (ii) the concerns that deferential reliance is broadly aesthetically problematic are overstated. Furthermore, (iii) the epistemic problems facing second-hand sources in this context are shared by reliance upon first-hand sources.
Senast uppdaterad: 2026-04-01
Sidansvarig: Filosofiska institutionen