Högre seminariet i teoretisk filosofi: Mikael Janvid

SEMINARIUM
Datum: torsdag 15 maj 2025
Tid: 13:15 - 15:00
Plats: D700

Anti-Social Black Metal Epistemology: Forming Beliefs without Trust in an Evil Environment

Seminarium

Datum:

torsdag 15 maj 2025

Tid:

13.15 – 15.00

Plats:

D700

Abstract

A grim picture of human existence and society is painted in the Norwegian Black Metal band Gorgoroth’s masterpiece album Quantos Possunt Ad Satanitatem Trahunt from 2009. Contrary to what has been preached to us and we have been indoctrinated in, Evil rules the world! Yet by embracing this dark outlook, the struggling subject gains a privileged epistemic insight freeing themselves from the hypocrisies of religion, political ideologies and other delusions.

This highly distrustful outlook challenges the central role trust is claimed to play by current influential views in social epistemology of testimony where trust in fellow humans is considered essential for our epistemic practices. This paper starts out from the perspective conveyed by the lyrics in this album, and others in the same genre, to explore just how meager of a social basis testimony can survive on. How would such a distrustful seeker of truth go about forming their beliefs? The central theme to be investigated is what role trust, as well as its contrary, plays in testimonial exchange. The paper aims to find out how such a subject could still succeed epistemically while violating accounts of trust presented in the recent debate. Lastly the question is posed whether the reader knows they are not in this dire predicament.

Senast uppdaterad: 2025-02-17

Sidansvarig: Department of Philosophy