CLLAM Seminar: Alice Damirjian (SU)
Speaking in ideology
In this talk, I argue that some linguistic practices are ideologically charged, but that there are (at least) two importantly different ways in which a linguistic practice can be ideologically charged. To briefly state the core idea: A linguistic practice p in a speech community c will be argued to be ideologically charged in c if (i) there is an ideology I in c such that p reproduces I in c, or (ii) there is an ideology I such that members of c are generally disposed to infer that a speaker who engages in p endorses I. The two phenomena here subsumed under the label ideological charge have already enjoyed sustained philosophical attention, particularly in discussions about slurs, hate speech, and dogwhistles. But when discussed, they are mostly treated separately or thought of as competing accounts of one and the same phenomenon. This, I contend, has obscured both their respective differences and their connection. To argue for the idea that language can be ideologically charged, I will consider three linguistic practices as case studies. I will show that each of these practices are plausibly, and in a quite intuitive sense, viewed as ideologically charged. However, I will also argue that they differ in what way they are so charged. This motivates the idea that there are two distinct ways in which a linguistic practice can be ideologically charged. To further motivate the introduced distinction, I show that a compelling solution to the so-called “slur creation problem” can be formulated on the basis of it.
Zoom link:
https://stockholmuniversity.zoom.us/j/8938261027?omn=61036029217
Last updated: 2026-03-26
Source: Department of Philosophy