Higher Seminar in Practical Philosophy: Greg Bognar (Stockholm University)

SEMINAR
Date: Tuesday 18 November 2025
Time: 13:15 - 15:00
Location: D700

Self-Ownership and the Moral Significance of Birth

Seminar

Date:

Tuesday 18 November 2025

Time:

13.15 – 15.00

Location:

D700

Abstract

According to moderate permissive views, abortion becomes increasingly problematic as the pregnancy develops. Late-term abortions require more momentous moral justification.

This, however, is thought to create a problem: other things being equal, some reasons that can justify late-term abortions can justify the killing of newborns as well. If the only difference between a late-term fetus and a newborn is their location, then the moral difference between abortion and infanticide cannot be maintained.

This is a well-known problem for moderate permissive views. It is widely accepted that birth itself has no moral significance.

In this paper, I challenge this consensus. I argue that there is a morally significant difference between the fetus and the newborn: the newborn acquires self-ownership at birth. This changes the balance of reasons: killing a newborn becomes morally more problematic than killing a fetus. Moderate permissive views can, after all, maintain the moral difference between abortion and infanticide. 

Last updated: 2025-11-11

Source: Department of Philosophy