Higher Seminar in Practical Philosophy: Stina Björkholm & Mats Ingelström (IFFS)
Does Contextualism about ‘Well-Being’ Challenge a Philosophical Paradigm?
Seminar
Date:
Tuesday 20 May 2025Time:
13.15 – 15.00Location:
D700Abstract
The concept of well-being plays a central role across a range of contexts, from empirical sciences and ethical theory to everyday discourse. Alexandrova has argued that the diversity of well-being discourse supports a semantic contextualist view – positing that the meaning of ‘well-being’ shifts depending on the context of use.
This thesis has been taken to challenge a traditional philosophical way of theorizing about well-being. In this paper, we challenge that contention. We begin by outlining the contextualist approach and presenting reasons to take it seriously as a semantic thesis.
We then address three ways of spelling out how this view might be at odds with a philosophical paradigm, demonstrating that neither succeeds in establishing that there is a genuine conflict.
Our analysis suggests that recognizing the contextual nature of well-being discourse does not entail that philosophy of well-being is undermined or significantly limits the relevance of the field.
Last updated: 2025-05-13
Source: Department of Philosophy