Swedish crime policy: knowledge or emotion?
Is it knowledge or emotion that forms the basis of our parliamentary politicians' criminal policy decisions? Johan Edman, professor at the Department of Criminology, will investigate this in a new research project.
Swedish crime policy is not based on what science proves works. And the situation has gotten worse over the years - Swedish politicians have become increasingly bad at listening to science. At least, that is a common perception among researchers, says Johan Edman. He is originally a historian and later a professor of criminology.

Johan Edman, professor, Kriminologiska institutionen vid Stockholms universitet. Foto: Sören Andersson
"In criminology, I found many descriptions, sometimes even frustration, that politicians did not use evidence-based knowledge when formulating their crime policy visions," he says.
The question is how things actually are. According to Johan Edman, a historical perspective is needed to understand contemporary policy. In his new research project ‘The knowledge base of Swedish criminal policy 1853–2024’, he will therefore investigate what knowledge Swedish criminal policy has been based on over the past 170 years.
"I want to investigate what our parliamentary politicians have known and wanted to know about crime. Have they based their crime policy on scientific studies, media coverage, personal knowledge - or what?"
What do politicians really know?
The project will first identify key crime policy issues between 1853-2024. Then the issues will be followed, from, for example, bills to discussions in Parliament. Among other things, the project will examine how problems were formulated, as well as their consequences, causes and solutions. What the politicians claim to know, and on what grounds, will also be studied.
"When is what considered a reasonable knowledge base for criminal policy claims? For example, is it something new to formulate policy based on perceptions of what intended voters want rather than what different researchers think works?"
“We need to step up our game”
The project consists of several sub-studies. This allows for comparisons between different criminal policy issues and over time. Johan Edman explains that the question marks need to be cleared up, otherwise there is a risk of major consequences.
"We just have to get our act together, both politicians and researchers. We cannot continue to talk past each other with obviously different agendas and pretend that we are playing the same game. That is ultimately democratically devastating."
He believes that it is possible to get further if the focus is instead on examining how different types of criminal policy relate to different types of knowledge use.
"Are we just disagreeing on what the best crime policy measures are, or do we also not have the same crime policy goals? And if so, shouldn't we be clearer about that? It would be democratically revitalising."
The project in short
- The project will examine what drives Swedish crime policy.
- Also whether this has changed over time.
- The project will be conducted between 2024-2027 and is funded by the Swedish Research Council with a grant of 4,635,000 kronor.
Last updated: 2025-05-16
Source: Department of Criminology